SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549
Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section
14(a) of the
Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Amendment No. )
|☑||Filed by the Registrant||☐||Filed by a party other than the Registrant|
|CHECK THE APPROPRIATE BOX:|
|☐||Preliminary Proxy Statement|
|☐||Confidential, for Use of the Commission Only (as permitted by Rule 14a-6(e)(2))|
|☑||Definitive Proxy Statement|
|☐||Definitive Additional Materials|
|☐||Soliciting Material under §240.14a-12|
(Name of Registrant as Specified In Its
(Name of Person(s) Filing Proxy Statement, if other than the Registrant)
|PAYMENT OF FILING FEE (CHECK ALL BOXES THAT APPLY):|
|☑||No fee required|
|☐||Fee paid previously with preliminary materials|
|☐||Fee computed on table in exhibit required by Item 25(b) per Exchange Act Rules 14a-6(i)(1) and 0-11|
Annual Meeting of Shareholders and Proxy Statement
We strive to bring greater
Bringing clarity to
Develop new research and models to help our clients better assess an increasingly complex and expanding global investment landscape
Measure and model environmental, social and governance (ESG) and climate risk and opportunities
Enhance our clients’ experience by leveraging technology to easily integrate into client workflows and deliver our solutions across multiple platforms
Achieve client-centricity by understanding our clients’ unique needs in the markets in which they operate and by providing excellent client support
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||3|
Looking ahead, we remain focused on being nimble and investing aggressively to meet client demand across the growth opportunities in front of us, including with respect to ESG and climate.
1 Recurring net new sales represent the amount of new recurring subscription sales net of subscription cancellations during the period.
Dear fellow shareholders,
First and foremost, thank you for your continued support of MSCI Inc. (“MSCI” or the “Company”). Thanks to MSCI’s more than 4,000 employees around the world, we delivered exceptional results in 2021, demonstrating the strength of our ambitious strategy, key long-term investments and relentless execution.
Our 2021 performance further speaks to the trust our clients place in us to help them navigate an increasingly complex investment landscape and our ability to continue to meet their needs. Among other milestones, at the end of 2021, we achieved record full-year and quarterly recurring sales and recurring net new sales1, along with the 32nd consecutive quarter of double-digit subscription growth in our Index product line.
We also affirmed our status as a leading provider of ESG and climate solutions for investors. We saw significant momentum in our ESG and Climate segment, resulting in nearly 50% top-line growth compared to the prior year. Throughout 2021, we rolled out several new climate tools, including an analytical tool that provides carbon emissions data for more than 15,000 private companies and nearly 4,000 active private equity and debt funds. This is in addition to our launch of Climate Lab Enterprise, a first-in-kind visualization dashboard that combines our climate data with our analytical risk and portfolio management capabilities, and the carbon emission data we already provide on nearly 10,000 public companies.
In 2021, we also saw a significant expansion of our capabilities with respect to private assets, with the completion of our acquisition of Real Capital Analytics, Inc. (“Real Capital Analytics” or “RCA”), a provider of data and analytics for the properties and transactions that drive the global commercial real estate capital markets. After this and other investments in our business, we returned approximately $440 million of cash to shareholders through a combination of dividends and share repurchases.
Positioning MSCI for the Future
Looking ahead, we remain focused on being nimble and investing aggressively to meet client demand across the growth opportunities in front of us, including with respect to ESG and climate. The global race
to net-zero keeps accelerating, and we aim to further position MSCI to become the top provider of ESG and climate solutions to the investment industry.
We will also continue to invest in our data-transformation strategy. This strategy was a direct result of the feedback we received from many of you. We plan to continue to rapidly incorporate new proprietary and third-party data sets to expand and enrich our existing content in order to generate more meaningful and richer insights for our clients. We are also continuing to create new pathways for clients to access and interact with our products, including by developing and launching our new open-architecture Investment Solutions as a Service (“ISaaS”) offerings, many of which can integrate with our clients’ existing ecosystems via APIs.
Doing our Part
For the last several years, including by publishing the MSCI Principles of Sustainable Investing, we have been urging all investors to integrate ESG and climate considerations into their investment processes in order to achieve long-term, sustainable investment performance. Since then, we have published reports, data and research to continue to provide clarity for investors so that they can make more informed decisions regarding material environmental, social and governance risks. We have also released tools that can help our clients navigate these efforts – tools that support our mission of enabling investors to build better portfolios for a better world. In 2022, we not only remain deeply committed to this objective, but we also aim to lead by example through our corporate responsibility policies and practices.
We Ask for Your Support
Your vote is very important to us. We strongly encourage you to read both our Proxy Statement and 2021 Annual Report on Form 10-K in their entirety and ask that you support our recommendations. We sincerely appreciate your continued support of MSCI, and we look forward to the 2022 Annual Meeting.
HENRY A. FERNANDEZ
Chairman, Chief Executive Officer and Shareholder
The Board’s role is critical in overseeing MSCI’s strategy, and we continue to work closely with management on matters regarding the business, its performance and its long-term outlook.
Dear fellow shareholders,
The independent directors of MSCI and I join Henry in inviting you to attend our Company’s 2022 Annual Meeting. It is a privilege to continue serving as your independent Lead Director during this important time for MSCI. As we approach the 2022 Annual Meeting, I am grateful for this opportunity to share with you some of the ways that the Board has worked together over the past year to provide independent oversight of areas that are important to you.
As a Board, we actively engage with our shareholders and gain firsthand information on the areas that matter most to them, including not just strategy and financial performance, but other key issues such as corporate responsibility, our efforts around diversity, equity and inclusion (“DE&I”), executive compensation and corporate governance. In the winter of 2021, during our Corporate Responsibility Roadshow, members of MSCI’s senior management engaged with top shareholders representing more than 40% of our shares outstanding. Members of the Governance and Corporate Responsibility Committee of the Board, Jacques Perold and Paula Volent, participated in discussions with several shareholders during these meetings. As detailed in this Proxy Statement, under “Shareholder Engagement,” we covered a range of topics, and the Board continues to use your input to inform our practices to ensure they align with shareholder interests. We welcome your continued engagement and feedback.
Board Composition and Process
An essential component of the Board leadership structure at MSCI is oversight by independent directors. As MSCI’s Lead Director, I am responsible for helping ensure that the Board exercises its role independent from the management
of the Company, as described in this Proxy Statement, under “Structure of our Board,” to ensure independent and effective oversight.
One of my priorities as Lead Director is to ensure the Board is comprised of directors who are equipped to oversee the risks and opportunities of this business. This year’s Board nominees represent a wide range of backgrounds and expertise. We believe our diversity of experiences, perspectives and skills contribute to the Board’s effectiveness in managing risk and providing guidance to position MSCI for long-term success across rapidly changing business environments for us and for our clients. Of the 10 Board nominees, 9 are independent, which includes all committee chairs and members.
We are pleased to announce the nomination of Rajat Taneja for election to the Board at our 2022 Annual Meeting. Rajat is President of Technology for Visa Inc., and has 30 years of global technology, innovation, and research and development experience. He has been a tremendous addition to the Board as we seek to increasingly leverage cutting-edge technologies to deliver enhanced user experiences and evolve MSCI’s cybersecurity program. Rajat’s appointment in 2021 was informed by the Board’s continued focus on its composition, as well as insights provided through the Board’s annual evaluation process, which includes both evaluation of the Board and its Committees as well as individual director evaluation through interviews that I conduct with each director.
We also consistently prioritize a focus on the Board’s processes and structures to ensure they remain effective. In 2021, we instituted a review of the roles and responsibilities of our committees. We enhanced our committee charters to reflect leading practices and renamed
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||5|
the Audit and Risk Committee; Compensation, Talent and Culture Committee; and Governance and Corporate Responsibility Committee to provide more clarity and transparency to stakeholders on areas of Board committee-level oversight. These changes in committee names and scope reflect the strategic significance that risk oversight, talent and culture management and corporate responsibility have to our long-term success, and they reflect the growing focus of these areas by our shareholders and the broader stakeholder community.
Commitment to Corporate Responsibility
The Board and its Governance and Corporate Responsibility Committee are actively engaged in overseeing MSCI’s corporate responsibility efforts, including to ensure that our practices complement our leadership in ESG and climate. Based on feedback from you, in 2021, we announced our net-zero commitment and increased the amount of reporting we prepare relating to our corporate responsibility efforts, including our first United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) report and our first Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulations (SFDR) report. In addition, we published our two most recent EEO-1 reports (containing demographic data for our U.S. employees by race/ethnicity, gender and job categories) as well as SASB-aligned diversity disclosure, and we have committed to doing so in the future. As you will see in this Proxy Statement, we have added a more detailed “Corporate Responsibility” section to provide transparency on the governance of our corporate responsibility efforts by the Board and management.
Our People and the Future of Work
We are committed to ensuring that MSCI’s programs related to our employees continue to support our people and our strategy during a period of rapid change. The Board fully appreciates that MSCI’s employees are an essential element of our long-term success, and we spent significant time in 2021 reviewing the Company’s approach to organizational development, talent development, DE&I initiatives and succession planning. In particular, we focused on flexibility in how and where our employees work, and in January 2022, we implemented our “Future of Work,” a hybrid work environment that utilizes pandemic lessons to allow our employees to work at times at the office and other times remotely, depending on the requirements of specific roles. Following an extensive organizational design assessment, we also announced several changes to senior management, as well as the expansion of
MSCI’s Executive Committee to include greater representation from key operating functions, in particular, Research, Technology and Data, and Private Assets.
In 2021, we also spent significant time reviewing the Company’s executive compensation program to ensure that MSCI is appropriately incentivizing long-term performance and shareholder value creation. Over the past several years, MSCI has chosen to incorporate a number of performance-based metrics and qualitative goals to reward exceptional performance, including by assessing performance against individualized DE&I goals, which are directly linked to a portion of each Managing Director’s annual incentive compensation. As we continue to promote an “owner-operator” mindset within the Company, we also significantly enhanced the stock ownership requirements applicable to our senior leaders. You can learn more about our executive compensation program in this Proxy Statement, under “Compensation Matters.”
Oversight of Strategy and Risk
The Board’s role is critical in overseeing MSCI’s strategy, and we continue to work closely with management on matters regarding the business, its performance and its long-term outlook. The Board sees an incredible opportunity for MSCI to continue to be a leader in the evolving global investment landscape, and, in 2021, our Board meetings regularly included consideration of significant business and organizational initiatives, capital allocation strategies and corporate development opportunities, including our acquisition of Real Capital Analytics in September. Throughout the year, the Board was also kept informed of enterprise risk and information technology risk developments, including our technology infrastructure, regulatory and compliance matters, public policy developments, risks and opportunities related to climate and go-to-market strategy.
On behalf of my fellow independent directors and the entire Board, thank you for your continued support. We appreciate the opportunity to serve MSCI on your behalf in 2022 and beyond. We look forward to hearing your views at the 2022 Annual Meeting and through our on-going engagement.
ROBERT G. ASHE
Independent Lead Director and Shareholder
Notice of Annual Meeting
Annual Meeting Proposals and Voting Recommendations
|1||Election of Directors||“FOR”
SEE PAGE 20
|2||Advisory Vote to Approve Executive Compensation (Say-on-Pay)||“FOR”
SEE PAGE 55
|3||Ratification of the Appointment of MSCI’s Independent Auditor||“FOR”
SEE PAGE 99
The virtual annual meeting will commence at 2:30 P.M., Eastern Time. Online check-in will be available beginning at 1:30 P.M., Eastern Time. Please allow ample time for the online check-in process.
To participate in the virtual annual meeting, you will need the 16-digit control number included on your Notice of Internet Availability of Proxy Materials, on your proxy card or on any additional voting instructions that accompanied your proxy materials.
A webcast replay of the 2022 annual meeting of shareholders (the “2022 Annual Meeting”) will also be made available on our Investor Relations website (https://ir.msci.com).
If you are a beneficial shareholder, your broker will not be able to vote your shares with respect to any of the matters presented at the meeting, other than the ratification of the selection of our independent registered public accounting firm, unless you give your broker specific voting instructions.
Important Notice Regarding the Availability of Proxy Materials for the 2022 Annual Meeting to be held on April 26, 2022. Our Proxy Statement and our 2021 Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2021 are available without charge at www.proxyvote.com. Information contained on such website is not incorporated by reference into this Proxy Statement or any other report we file with the SEC.
DATE AND TIME
APRIL 26, 2022 (Tuesday)
2:30 P.M., EASTERN TIME
Attend the virtual meeting, including to vote and/or submit questions via the internet through a virtual web conference at:
MARCH 1, 2022
How to Vote
Whether or not you plan to attend our 2022 Annual Meeting, it is important that you vote as soon as possible to ensure that your shares are represented.
Use the internet to transmit your voting instructions and for electronic delivery of information up until 11:59 P.M. Eastern Time on April 25, 2022. Have your proxy card in hand when you access the website and follow the instructions to obtain your records and to create an electronic voting instruction form.
Use any touch-tone telephone to transmit your voting instructions up until 11:59 P.M. Eastern Time on April 25, 2022. Have your proxy card in hand when you call and then follow the instructions.
Mark, sign and date your proxy card and return it in the postage- paid envelope we have provided or return it to Vote Processing, c/o Broadridge, 51 Mercedes Way, Edgewood, NY 11717.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||7|
from our Chairman and CEO
from our Independent Lead Director|
No. 1: Election of Directors
|21||Director Core Competencies and Diversity|
|23||2022 Director Nominees|
|29||Robust Corporate Governance Practices|
|30||Composition and Board Refreshment|
|32||Structure of our Board|
|38||Engagement and Evaluation of our Board|
|41||Oversight by our Board|
|48||Human Capital Management|
Director Compensation and Stock Ownership Guidelines
No. 2: Advisory Vote to Approve Executive Compensation (Say-on-Pay)
|57||Compensation Discussion and Analysis|
|63||Governance and Administration|
|69||Review of our Programs|
|85||Compensation Risk Assessment|
|86||Compensation, Talent and Culture Committee Report|
|87||Executive Compensation Tables|
|96||Independent Auditor’s Fees|
|96||Pre-Approval Policy of the Audit and Risk Committee of Services Performed by Independent Auditors|
|97||Audit and Risk Committee Report|
No. 3: Ratification of the Appointment of MSCI Inc.’s Independent Auditor
Ownership of Common Stock|
|100||Stock Ownership of Executive Officers and Directors|
|101||Stock Ownership of Principal Shareholders|
|102||Corporate Governance Documents|
|103||Related Person Transactions Policy|
A: Frequently Asked Questions|
B: Supplemental Financial Information
NOTE ON FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS
This Proxy Statement contains forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. These forward-looking statements relate to future events or to future financial performance and involve known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors that may cause our actual results, levels of activity, performance or achievements to be materially different from any future results, levels of activity, performance or achievements expressed or implied by these statements. In some cases, you can identify forward-looking statements by the use of words such as “may,” “could,” “expect,” “intend,” “plan,” “seek,” “anticipate,” “believe,” “estimate,” “predict,” “potential” or “continue,” or the negative of these terms or other comparable terminology. You should not place undue reliance on forward-looking statements because they involve known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors that are, in some cases, beyond our control and that could materially affect our actual results, levels of activity, performance or achievements.
Other factors that could materially affect actual results, levels of activity, performance or achievements can be found in the 2021 Annual Report on Form 10-K filed with the SEC on February 11, 2022 and in quarterly reports on Form 10-Q and current reports on Form 8-K filed or furnished with the SEC. If any of these risks or uncertainties materialize, or if our underlying assumptions prove to be incorrect, actual results may vary significantly from what MSCI projected. Any forward-looking statement in this Proxy Statement reflects MSCI’s current views with respect to future events and is subject to these and other risks, uncertainties and assumptions relating to MSCI’s operations, results of operations, growth strategy and liquidity. MSCI assumes no obligation to publicly update or revise these forward-looking statements for any reason, whether as a result of new information, future events or otherwise, except as required by law.
Information and reports on our website or other websites that we refer to in this Proxy Statement will not be deemed a part of, or otherwise incorporated by reference in, this Proxy Statement or any other report we file with the SEC.
This summary highlights information contained elsewhere in this Proxy Statement. It does not contain all of the information that you should consider, and you should read the entire Proxy Statement carefully before voting.
MSCI at a Glance
MSCI Inc. trades under the symbol “MSCI” on the New York Stock Exchange (“NYSE”) and as of March 1, 2022 had a market capitalization of $40.7 billion.
As of December 31, 2021,
4,303 people and served over
6,300 clients in more than
We are a leading provider of critical decision support tools and solutions for the global investment community. Our mission-critical offerings help investors address the challenges of a transforming investment landscape and power better investment decisions. Leveraging our knowledge of the global investment process and our expertise in research, data and technology, we enable our clients to understand and analyze key drivers of risk and return and confidently and efficiently build more effective portfolios.
To enable investors to build better portfolios for a better world.
Strategic Pillars of Growth
Extend leadership in research-enhanced content across asset
Lead the enablement of ESG and climate investment integration
Enhance distribution and content-enabling technology
Expand solutions that empower client customization
Strengthen client relationships and grow into strategic partnerships with clients
Execute strategic relationships and acquisitions with complementary content and technology companies
Addressing All Participants in the Investment Process
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||9|
Strong Financial Performance
In 2021, we continued to execute a focused strategy to accelerate growth, improve efficiency and attract the best talent. Our strong results reflect our commitment to building long-term shareholder value. Financial highlights for the year ended December 31, 2021 include the following:
2021 Financial Highlights
(in millions except percentages)
|OPERATING EXPENSES |
(in millions except percentages)
|DILUTED EPS / ADJUSTED EPS*
|CASH FROM OPERATING ACTIVITIES |
(in millions except percentages)
|*||MSCI has presented supplemental non-GAAP financial measures as part of this Proxy Statement. Definitions of each non-GAAP measure and a reconciliation of each non-GAAP financial measure with the most comparable GAAP measure are set forth in Annex B. The non-GAAP financial measures presented in this Proxy Statement should not be considered as alternative measures for the most directly comparable GAAP financial measures. The non-GAAP financial measures presented in this Proxy Statement are used by management to monitor the financial performance of the business, inform business decision making and forecast future results.|
|10||MSCI | PROXY SUMMARY|
Our Capital Allocation Program
Capital returned in the last
five years (as of December 31, 2021)
Shares repurchased in the
last five years
(as of December 31, 2021)
2021 increase in quarterly per-share
dividend from $0.78 quarterly to
ANNUALIZED DIVIDEND RATES
|(1)||MSCI began paying quarterly dividends in September 2014 at an annualized rate of $0.72 per share.|
Capital Optimization Activities in 2021
|●||Increased regular quarterly cash dividend by approximately 33.3% to $1.04 per share, representing $4.16 per share on an annualized basis.|
|●||Repurchased over 300,000 shares of our common stock at an average price of $412.25 per share for a total value of $140 million.|
|●||Issued $500 million of 3.625% senior unsecured notes due 2030; leveraged lower coupon rate for pre-maturity redemption of $500 million of 4.750% senior unsecured notes due 2026.|
|●||Issued $600 million of 3.625% senior unsecured notes due 2031.|
|●||Issued $700 million of 3.250% senior unsecured notes due 2033; leveraged lower coupon rate for pre-maturity redemption of $500 million of 5.375% senior unsecured notes due 2027.|
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||11|
Total Shareholder Return
The following graph compares the cumulative total shareholders’ return (“TSR”) of our common stock, the Standard & Poor’s 500 Stock Index and the NYSE Composite Index since December 31, 2011 assuming an investment of $100 at the closing price of each respective investment on December 31, 2011. In calculating annual TSR, we have assumed the reinvestment of dividends, if any. The indexes are included for comparative purposes only. They do not necessarily reflect management’s opinion that such indexes are an appropriate measure of the relative performance of our common stock.
COMPARISON OF CUMULATIVE TEN YEAR TOTAL RETURN
The above graph is not “soliciting material,” is not to be deemed filed with the SEC and is not to be incorporated by reference in any of our filings under the Securities Act of 1933 or the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (the “Exchange Act”), whether made before or after the date hereof and irrespective of any general incorporation language in any such filing.
|S&P 500 Index||$100.00||$||116.00||$153.57||$174.60||$177.01||$198.18||$241.45||$230.86||$303.56||$||359.41||$||462.57|
|NYSE Composite Index||$100.00||$||116.03||$146.52||$156.41||$150.02||$167.92||$199.37||$181.53||$227.84||$||243.76||$||294.16|
Source: S&P Global
|12||MSCI | PROXY SUMMARY|
We believe, and our research shows, that sound ESG and climate practices are commonly linked to better business results. We provide the global financial community with innovative products and services that enable investors to make better investment decisions for a better world. As a leader in providing ESG and climate solutions to investors, we also aim to demonstrate leading corporate responsibility practices.
Our commitment to corporate responsibility is embodied in the following four pillars:
Better Investments for a Better World
Offer tools and content for investors globally to manage their ESG and climate risks and opportunities
● ESG and Climate Research
● Published “The Role of Capital in the Net-Zero Revolution” to identify specific steps to drive to a net-zero economy by 2050
● Published the “Women on Boards Progress Report,” our annual survey on the state of women’s representation on corporate boards
● Published “Breaking Down Corporate Net-Zero Climate Targets” to provide a framework to assess companies’ decarbonization targets
● Data and Metrics Published
● Launched our Implied Temperature Rise search tool, which discloses how individual companies align with different climate pathways and decarbonization targets
● Launched the MSCI Net-Zero Tracker to gauge progress by the world’s public companies toward curbing climate risk
● Released the U.S. Racial and Ethnic Data Set to provide information on select U.S. companies’ disclosure practices and policies with regards to racial and ethnic diversity
● Product Launches and Initiatives
● Launched our MSCI Climate Lab Enterprise product to help investors monitor and manage climate risk across the investment process
● Expanded our toolkit of climate data and reporting capabilities to help investors meet the requirements of the E.U. Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (“SFDR”)
● Together with The Burgiss Group, LLC (“Burgiss”), launched the Carbon Footprinting of Private Equity and Debt Funds product to measure the carbon intensity of private assets
● ESG and Climate Index Launches
● Introduced MSCI Climate Paris Aligned Indexes, designed to support investors seeking to reduce their exposure to transition and physical climate risks
● Launched a new suite of Circular Economy Indexes that aim to represent the performance of companies that facilitate a transition to a circular economy, addressing global resource challenges such as energy scarcity, biodiversity loss, waste and pollution
Build a highly engaged workforce, including through learning and development efforts and DE&I initiatives
● Diversity Equity & Inclusion (DE&I)
● Hired our first Chief Diversity Officer, responsible for operating across MSCI to align our DE&I goals with business outcomes, help embed DE&I considerations in the way we do business, attract and retain the best diverse talent and increase the impact of our internal workplace initiatives
● Published our 2020 and 2019 U.S. Consolidated EEO- 1 Report data, in addition to disclosing diversity data aligned to Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (“SASB”) categories
● Formed three new DE&I employee resource groups (“ERGs”), the Asian Support Network, All Abilities Network and Hola! MSCI
● Executed 4th Annual Global DE&I Summit, an internal event that focuses on leadership development and strategic planning
● All Managing Directors created, and were held accountable for, individual DE&I Goals directly linked to their 2021 compensation
● Enhanced Executive Committee Share Ownership Guidelines to be one of the most robust in our peer group and to reflect MSCI’s deep commitment to an “owner-operator” mindset
● Employee Engagement: In our most recent employee engagement survey (not including employees from newly acquired companies), the percentage of respondents characterized as “fully engaged” equaled the highest since implementing the survey
● Future of Work: Launched our Future of Work initiative that introduces increased flexibility of when and where employees work, reimagines the use of our offices and ramps up the use of technology to enhance our interactions with clients and employees
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||13|
Manage carbon emissions and climate risks, and implement sustainable operational practices
● New Commitments
● Committed to a goal of net-zero carbon emissions before 2040 throughout our operations, prioritizing reducing our most material and controllable emissions and engaging with our suppliers
● Committed to support all of the United Nations (“UN”) Sustainability Development Goals (“SDGs”) and aim to measure impact for SDGs relating to gender equality, decent work and economic growth, reduced inequality and climate action
● External Recognition: Improved our CDP score to reach leadership score of A-
● Expanding Alliances
● Became a founding member of the Net Zero Financial Service Providers Alliance, committing to align our relevant services and products with a 2050 net-zero emissions target
● Participated in, and met with policymakers and financial regulators at, the UN Climate Change Conference (COP26)
● Engaging with our Suppliers
● Updated Supplier Code of Conduct to address emissions in the MSCI supply chain. Prioritized engagement with major suppliers to align net-zero goals
● Developed an internal Sustainable Supplier Management Team to support efforts to learn about our suppliers’ corporate responsibility practices and seek alignment with our own commitments
● New Reporting
● Published first SFDR report
● Published first UN SDGs report
● Updating our Policies
● Updated our Environmental Policy to include our commitment to net-zero and to environmental issues (e.g., biodiversity, waste and water)
● Updated our Travel Policy to encourage employees to prioritize virtual meetings and use of low carbon travel options
Implement policies and practices that reflect MSCI’s commitment to strong governance practices
● Board Developments
● Appointed Rajat Taneja, a new director with a deep background in technology
● Enhanced Board Committee Charters to reflect leading practices and renamed the Audit and Risk Committee, Compensation, Talent and Culture Committee and Governance and Corporate Responsibility Committee to provide more clarity and transparency on Board committee-level oversight
● Conducted board education sessions to strengthen the Board’s expertise on climate, including sessions on climate science, climate investing, climate reporting solutions and net-zero commitments
● Corporate Responsibility Governance
● Formed a Corporate Responsibility Policy Committee (“CRPC”), responsible for reviewing strategic corporate responsibility initiatives
● Expanded the Corporate Responsibility Committee (“CRC”) to include new members from DE&I, Technology, Data Management, Client Coverage, Controllership and Financial Planning & Analysis teams.
● Risk Oversight: Integrated climate and DE&I into our risk management program, with reporting to the Audit and Risk Committee
For additional information about our Corporate Responsibility Program, please see page 45 of this Proxy Statement.
|14||MSCI | PROXY SUMMARY|
Our Board of Directors Nominees
Each of our current directors is standing for election to hold office until the next annual meeting of shareholders or until the director’s earlier resignation, death or removal. The table below provides information on each of our director nominees, including which of our four standing committees the director nominee sits on. Our four standing committees are the Audit and Risk Committee (the “Audit Committee”), the Compensation, Talent and Culture Committee (the “Compensation Committee”), the Governance and Corporate Responsibility Committee (the “Governance Committee”) and the Strategy and Finance Committee (the “Strategy Committee”).
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||15|
Election of Directors
The Board recommends a vote
FOR each director nominee.
SEE PAGE 20
|16||MSCI | PROXY SUMMARY|
Engaging with our Shareholders
We believe that engaging with our shareholders, prospective shareholders and sell-side analysts is the best way to address the issues that matter most to them. During 2021, we held over 300 meetings covering a wide range of matters. While we aim to engage with our shareholders year-round through investor meetings and industry conferences, our key shareholder engagement activities for 2021 included our Investor Day held in February 2021 and our Corporate Responsibility Roadshow conducted in the winter of 2021.
Team and Global
OUR CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY EFFORTS
Corporate Responsibility Practices and Disclosures, including ESG & Climate
Human Capital Management, including DE&I
Executive Compensation Program
meetings with our shareholders, prospective shareholders and sell-side analysts, including successful Investor Day and Corporate Responsibility Roadshow
~58% of our shares outstanding
represented across our shareholder engagement meetings in 2021
See “Shareholder Engagement” on page 40 for more information on our year-round shareholder engagement activities.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||17|
Advisory Vote to Approve Executive Compensation (Say-on-Pay)
The Board recommends a vote
FOR this proposal.
SEE PAGE 55
Aligning Executive Compensation with Company Strategy, Culture and Performance
We believe our executive compensation program was integral to our successful financial performance in 2021. Our executive compensation program is designed not only to closely align the compensation and interests of our named executive officers (“NEOs”) with the long-term interests of our shareholders, but also to reflect the economic realities of our operating environment. MSCI’s executive compensation program emphasizes performance-based compensation in the form of cash incentive awards under our Annual Incentive Plan (“AIP”) and equity incentive awards under our Long-Term Incentive Plan (“LTIP”) that focus respectively on the achievement of short- and long-term financial and strategic targets.
(ANNUAL INCENTIVE PLAN CASH BONUS)
● Restricted Stock Units (for 2021, ratable vest, and for 2022, cliff-vest after a three-year service period)
● Performance Stock Units (earned based on absolute TSR CAGR) with a 1-year post vesting mandatory holding period for 3-Year PSUs
● Performance Stock Options (earned based on cumulative revenue and cumulative Adjusted EPS) (new for 2022)
|2021 ANNUALIZED CEO||2021 AVERAGE ANNUALIZED OTHER NEOS|
In 2021, our CEO received over 90% of his compensation in the form of “at-risk” variable compensation under the AIP and LTIP (on average, over 85% in the case of our other NEOs).
Annual Incentive Plan
The AIP closely aligns the interests of our NEOs with those of our shareholders by emphasizing a formulaic approach to determine annual cash incentive awards, which are based on the achievement of specified annual financial criteria aligned with our Board-approved Operating Plan (70% of the target annual cash bonus under the AIP), individual key performance indicators (“KPIs”) (20% of the target annual cash bonus under the AIP) and specific DE&I goals (“DE&I Goals”) (10% of the target annual cash bonus under the AIP) that serve to focus our senior management team on enhancing DE&I progress within the Company. The Compensation Committee regularly assesses the components and metrics used in the AIP and the weighting of those components and metrics, in addition to taking into account shareholder feedback.
For additional information about the 2021 AIP program, please see the discussion on page 71 of this Proxy Statement.
|18||MSCI | PROXY SUMMARY|
Long-Term Incentive Plan
The LTIP is designed to prioritize shareholder value creation and facilitate an “owner-operator” mindset among our senior executives.
In 2021, we granted our NEOs a mix of RSUs and PSUs (including separate awards of PSUs with a 3-year cumulative performance period (“3-Year PSUs”) and PSUs with a 5-year cumulative performance period (“5-Year PSUs”)), the mix of which varies based on the executive’s position. Consistent with our recent practice, each of our CEO and President & COO received 100% of his equity incentive compensation in 2021 in the form of PSUs. In addition, for 2021, the Compensation Committee increased the proportion of our President & COO’s 5-Year PSUs from 50% to 60% of his overall equity incentive compensation (with the remaining 40% granted in the form of 3-Year PSUs), commensurate with our CEO.
In 2022, the Compensation Committee enhanced our LTIP by introducing a new award vehicle into the program: financial-based performance stock options (“PSOs”) that cover a cumulative three-year performance period and replace the grant of 5-Year PSUs.
The 2022 LTIP comprises a mix of the following:
Annual grant of RSUs to our NEOs (other than our CEO and President & COO) that cliff-vest at the end of a three-year service period. This reflects a change from ratable vesting over three years for RSUs granted prior to 2022.
● Our CEO and President & COO were not granted any RSUs in 2021 or 2022, and instead all of their LTIP awards for such years were granted in the form of PSUs and PSOs tied to performance metrics.
Annual grant of PSUs which cover a cumulative three-year performance period.
The 3-Year PSUs are eligible to vest between 0% and 300% based on the achievement of an absolute total shareholder return compound annual growth rate (“TSR CAGR”) performance metric.
The 3-Year PSUs include a one-year post-vest mandatory holding period.
Annual grant of PSOs which cover a cumulative three-year performance period.
The PSOs are eligible to vest between 0% and 200% based on the combined level of achievement of (i) a cumulative revenue performance goal and (ii) a cumulative adjusted EPS performance goal (each weighted at 50%).
For additional information about the LTIP, please see the discussion beginning on page 79 of this Proxy Statement.
Increased Stock Ownership and Retention Requirements
In 2022, in order to further enhance an “owner-operator” mindset among senior executives, our Compensation Committee amended our existing share ownership and retention guidelines to require that all members of our Executive Committee, including our NEOs, must hold shares equivalent, in the aggregate, to 25% of the “net shares” they receive (i.e., after payment of taxes, exercise price and related costs) from equity awards granted to them after January 1, 2022. The Compensation Committee also approved revisions to the minimum ownership guidelines to increase the thresholds applicable to members of our Executive Committee, including our NEOs, to among the highest in our peer group (including 12x base salary for our CEO and President & COO). For additional information about our Share Ownership and Retention Guidelines applicable to our NEOs, please see page 83 of this Proxy Statement.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||19|
Executive Compensation Highlights
Over the past several years, we have continued to enhance our executive compensation program to align with shareholder interests more closely and to further incentivize our executives to focus on the long-term execution of our strategic priorities to create shareholder value. The table below highlights certain key elements of, and enhancements to, our executive compensation program over the past several years.
● No changes made to 2020 Operating Plan or annual cash incentive targets for 2020 under AIP in response to challenging operating environment
● 97.8% of the votes cast on the Say-on-Pay Advisory Vote at the 2020 annual meeting of shareholders were in support of the compensation of our NEOs
● No increase to CEO base salary or total target cash incentive award for 2020
● CEO received all of his LTIP awards in the form of PSUs, and increased proportion of his 5-Year PSUs from 50% to 60% of total CEO equity compensation for 2020
● President & COO began receiving all of his LTIP awards in the form of PSUs
● CEO and President & COO received all of their LTIP awards in the form of PSUs
● Added a 1-year post-vest mandatory holding period to 3-Year PSU awards
● 96.8% of the votes cast on the Say-on-Pay Advisory Vote at the 2021 annual meeting of shareholders were in support of the compensation of our NEOs
● No increase to CEO and President & COO base salaries, total target cash incentive awards or target LTIP awards for 2021
● President & COO increased proportion of 5-Year PSUs from 50% to 60% (commensurate with CEO)
● Linked 10% of the target AIP cash incentive for all Managing Directors globally to achievement of DE&I Goals
● Introduced PSOs as new equity vehicle
● CEO and President & COO received all of their LTIP awards in the form of 3-Year PSUs and PSOs, tied to performance metrics
● Annual grant of RSUs for other NEOs will cliff-vest at the end of a three-year service period
● Retained 1-year post-vest mandatory holding period on 3-Year PSU awards
● Increased minimum share ownership requirements applicable to all members of our Executive Committee, including our CEO and President & COO to 12X base salary
● Added requirement that while members of the Executive Committee, such individuals including our NEOs, must hold shares equivalent, in the aggregate, to 25% of the “net shares” they receive from equity awards granted to them after January 1, 2022
● No increase to CEO and President & COO base salaries or total target cash incentive awards for 2022
● All Executive Committee members included a climate commitment goal in their 2022 individual KPIs under the AIP
Response to Say-on-Pay Vote
At our 2021 annual meeting of shareholders, stockholders again expressed overwhelming support for the compensation of our NEOs with approximately 96.8% of the votes cast approving our “Say on Pay” advisory proposal relating to our NEO compensation. This represents the fourth consecutive year of “Say on Pay” approval of 96% or higher.
To read more about what our shareholders think of our Executive Compensation program, see the discussion on page 67 of this Proxy Statement.
Ratification of the Appointment of MSCI’s Independent Auditor
The Board recommends a vote
FOR this proposal.
SEE PAGE 99
The Audit and Risk Committee periodically reviews the engagement of the independent auditor to assess, among other things, the skills, experience, service levels and costs associated with conducting the annual audit of the Company’s financial statements. PwC has served as our independent auditor since March 2014.
Our Board currently has 10 directors. Each director stands for election at each annual meeting of shareholders and holds office until his or her successor has been duly elected and qualified or the director’s earlier resignation, death or removal. All of the nominees presented beginning on page 14 of this Proxy Statement are directors of MSCI as of March 16, 2022. All directors, other than Rajat Taneja, were elected at the 2021 annual meeting of shareholders. The Board believes that each of the nominees brings strong skills and experience to the Board, giving the Board, as a group, the appropriate skills needed to exercise its oversight responsibilities and advise management with respect to the Company’s strategic initiatives.
Each nominee has indicated that he or she is willing and able to serve if elected. We do not anticipate that any nominee will be unable or unwilling to stand for election, but if that happens, your proxy vote will be cast for another person nominated by the Board, or the Board may elect to reduce its size.
VOTE REQUIRED AND RECOMMENDATION
The affirmative vote of a majority of the votes cast with respect to each director’s election at our 2022 Annual Meeting is required to approve Proposal No. 1. Abstentions shall not be treated as votes cast. For additional information on the consequences for directors who do not receive a majority of the votes cast, please refer to “What happens if a director does not receive a majority of the votes required for his or her re-election?” in Annex A.
Our Board recommends that you vote “FOR” the election of all ten nominees named below.
Proxies solicited by our Board will be voted “FOR” these nominees unless otherwise instructed.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||21|
|Director Core Competencies and Diversity|
|The Governance Committee believes the director skills, experiences and backgrounds set forth in the tables below are those most relevant to the Board’s oversight responsibilities and the Company’s strategic direction and strives to ensure that the Board includes a balanced mix of qualifications and backgrounds. Additional detail on each director nominee’s experiences and qualifications follows their biographies beginning on page 23 of this Proxy Statement.|
|Public company CEO or senior executive experience managing a complex organization with oversight of strategy, corporate development, talent management, business operations and/or overall decision making, and a consistent record of executing strategy and creating shareholder value through operational excellence.|
|GOVERNANCE/PUBLIC COMPANY BOARD||8/10|
|Experience in public company corporate governance related issues, policies and best practices, serving on a public company board and familiarity with corporate board topics.|
|Experience working as a senior executive in the financial services industry with our client segments (e.g., asset owners, broker-dealers, hedge funds and investment managers) and investment products and support tools.|
|GLOBAL PERSPECTIVE/INTERNATIONAL EXPERIENCE||8/10|
|Experience as a senior executive working for an international company or working or living in countries outside of the U.S.|
|Experience in operating businesses in similarly regulated industries, interacting with regulators and policymakers and/or working in government.|
|INVESTMENTS/STRATEGY AND CORPORATE DEVELOPMENT||9/10|
|Experience in financial investment markets and investment decisions, strategy and corporate development to maximize return for our shareholders, including cross-border investment and M&A and capital markets transactions.|
|Experience in accounting and financial reporting or experience as a financial expert and/or public company CFO, or audit partner from one of the big four audit firms.|
|Experience in risk management with oversight and assessment of different types of risk (including ERM, IT, credit, market, operational liquidity, business and reputational).|
|Experience in sales, marketing, brand development and interpreting client behaviors.|
|INNOVATION, DATA AND TECHNOLOGY||9/10|
|Experience with innovative technology, digital content or enterprise technology-driven issues such as privacy, cybersecurity, data management, and the regulatory landscape surrounding technological development.|
|CORPORATE, ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL AFFAIRS||9/10|
|Experience in corporate affairs, philanthropy, community development, diversity, environmental, corporate and social responsibility and/or in investor relations.|
|HUMAN CAPITAL MANAGEMENT/EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION||9/10|
|Experience with making executive compensation decisions, including understanding the regulatory and financial considerations to take into account when making such decisions, and human capital management, including issues relating to succession planning; talent development, including performance reviews of executives; diversity, equity and inclusion; and culture.|
|22||MSCI | PROPOSAL NO. 1: ELECTION OF DIRECTORS|
|DIRECTOR CORE COMPETENCIES||Ashe||Edmunds||Fernandez||Kinney||Perold||Rattray||Riefler||Smith||Taneja||Volent|
|Governance/Public Company Board||●||●||●||●||●||●||●||●|
|Global Perspective/International Experience||●||●||●||●||●||●||●||●|
|Investments/Strategy and Corporate Development||●||●||●||●||●||●||●||●||●|
|Innovation, Data and Technology||●||●||●||●||●||●||●||●||●|
|Corporate, Environmental and Social Affairs||●||●||●||●||●||●||●||●||●|
|Human Capital Management/Executive Compensation||●||●||●||●||●||●||●||●||●|
|Alaskan Native/Native American|
|Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander|
|Two or More Races|
|Born Outside of the U.S.||●||●||●||●||●|
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||23|
Director since: 2013
Age: 62 years old
Audit Committee (Member)
ROBERT G. ASHE
Independent Lead Director
Mr. Ashe retired from IBM Corporation (“IBM”) in January 2012, where he had most recently served as General Manager of Business Analytics from 2010 to 2012 and before that as General Manager of Business Intelligence and Performance Management since 2008, following IBM’s acquisition of Cognos Inc. (“Cognos”), a Canadian provider of business intelligence and performance management software. Mr. Ashe worked for Cognos from 1984 to 2008, holding various executive positions, including most recently President and Chief Executive Officer from 2004 to 2008, President and Chief Operating Officer from 2002 to 2004 and Chief Corporate Officer from 2001 to 2002, during a portion of which time he also served as Chief Financial Officer. He also held various Senior Vice President positions in Worldwide Field Operations, Products and Application Development Tools from 1996 to 2001. Prior to that, he held various Vice President roles within Product Development and Corporate Finance. Mr. Ashe holds a Bachelor of Commerce from the University of Ottawa. Mr. Ashe is also a Certified Public Accountant in Canada.
CURRENT OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY DIRECTORSHIPS:
Shopify Inc. (May 2015 to present)
PRIOR OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY DIRECTORSHIPS:
ServiceSource International, Inc. (March 2013 to May 2020) and Halogen
We believe that Mr. Ashe’s over 30 years of experience in the technology sector, including his oversight of product marketing, software development, revenue growth initiatives and strategic transactions, render him qualified to serve as one of our directors. As a member of other public company boards and the former CEO of a public company, Mr. Ashe also brings to the Board insight with respect to the Board’s roles and responsibilities that are vital to his role as our Lead Director.
|24||MSCI | PROPOSAL NO. 1: ELECTION OF DIRECTORS|
Director since: 2015
Age: 66 years old
Audit Committee (Chair)
Mr. Edmunds previously served as the Interim Group Chief Executive of BBA Aviation plc from July 2017 to March 2018. He previously served as Chief Executive Officer of Invensys plc at Invensys Systems, Inc. (“Invensys”) from 2011 until his retirement in 2014. Previously, Mr. Edmunds was Chief Financial Officer of Invensys. Prior to joining Invensys in 2008, Mr. Edmunds was Senior Vice President of Finance at Reuters America, Inc. from 2005 to 2008. Mr. Edmunds served as the Chief Financial Officer of Innovance Networks Inc. (“Innovance”) from 2000 to 2004, where he was responsible for financial planning and operations. Prior to joining Innovance, Mr. Edmunds held other senior management roles in the technology sector, including working 17 years at Lucent Technologies, Inc., where he served as Vice President of Finance for the Optical Networking Division and as Vice President of Marketing and Business Development and was responsible for Europe, Middle East and Africa operations. Mr. Edmunds began his career at Amerada Hess Oil as an analyst in Corporate Treasury. Mr. Edmunds holds a Bachelor of Arts in accounting from Rutgers University and an M.B.A. in finance from Pace University.
PRIOR OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY DIRECTORSHIPS:
Signature Aviation plc (August 2013 to June 2021), Dialight plc (February 2016 to August 2019) and Ashtead Group plc (February 2014 to September 2018)
We believe that Mr. Edmunds’ extensive insight into global companies in the technology sector and his memberships on the Boards of multiple international companies render him qualified to serve as one of our directors.
Director since: 2007
Age: 63 years old
HENRY A. FERNANDEZ
Chairman and CEO
Mr. Fernandez has served as Chairman of our Board since 2007 and as our CEO and a director since 1998. He also served as head of the MSCI business from 1996 to 1998 and as President from 1998 to October 2017. Before leading MSCI’s transition to becoming a fully independent, standalone public company in 2007, he was a Managing Director at Morgan Stanley, where he worked in emerging markets business strategy, equity derivatives sales and trading, mergers and acquisitions, and corporate and mortgage finance. Mr. Fernandez worked for Morgan Stanley from 1983 to 1991 and from 1994 to 2007. Mr. Fernandez holds a Bachelor of Arts in economics from Georgetown University, an M.B.A. from the Stanford University Graduate School of Business and pursued doctoral studies in economics at Princeton University.
CURRENT OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY DIRECTORSHIPS:
Royalty Pharma plc (August 2020 to present)
We believe that Mr. Fernandez’s extensive experience and leadership in the financial services industry as well as his unparalleled knowledge of MSCI and its business, including as our Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, render him qualified to serve as one of our directors.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||25|
Director since: 2009
Age: 70 years old
Governance Committee (Member)
CATHERINE R. KINNEY
Ms. Kinney retired from NYSE Euronext in March 2009, having served as a Co-President and Co-Chief Operating Officer from 2002 to 2008. From 2007 to 2009, she served in Paris overseeing global listings, marketing and branding, and served as part of the integration team following the merger of NYSE and Euronext in April 2007. Ms. Kinney joined NYSE in 1974 and rose through the ranks holding management positions with responsibility for several divisions, including: all client relationships from 1996 to 2007, trading floor operations and technology from 1987 to 1996 and regulation from 2002 to 2004. Ms. Kinney holds a Bachelor of Arts from Iona College and has completed the Advanced Management Program at Harvard Graduate School of Business. She has received honorary degrees from Georgetown University, Fordham University and Rosemont College.
CURRENT OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY DIRECTORSHIPS:
MetLife Inc. (April 2009 to present) and SolarWinds Corporation (October 2018 to present)
PRIOR OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY DIRECTORSHIPS:
QTS Realty Trust, Inc. (August 2013 to September 2021)
We believe that Ms. Kinney’s management experience, including her role in overseeing a multinational business, as well as her expertise in corporate governance, including her role in developing the NYSE corporate governance standards for listed companies, render her qualified to serve as one of our directors.
Director since: 2017
Age: 63 years old
Governance Committee (Chair)
JACQUES P. PEROLD
Mr. Perold was president of Fidelity Management & Research Company, the investment advisor for Fidelity’s family of mutual funds, until his retirement in 2014. From 2001 to 2009, Mr. Perold was president of Geode Capital Management, LLC, a sub-advisor to Fidelity. He is currently a trustee of New York Life Insurance Company’s MainStay mutual funds, a trustee of Partners in Health, and a co-founder, CEO and Chairman of CapShift, a company focused on enabling impact investments from donor-advised funds and foundations. Mr. Perold holds a Bachelor of Arts degree in economic history from the University of Cape Town and a post-graduate Bachelor of Arts Honours degree in sociology from the University of Cape Town.
CURRENT OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY DIRECTORSHIPS:
Allstate Corporation (December 2015 to present)
We believe that Mr. Perold’s over 30 years of experience and leadership in strategy and operations as well as experience as an investment professional at one of the world’s largest asset management firms render him qualified to serve as one of our directors.
|26||MSCI | PROPOSAL NO. 1: ELECTION OF DIRECTORS|
Director since: 2020
Age: 52 years old
Audit Committee (Member)
SANDY C. RATTRAY
Mr. Rattray retired from Man Group plc in September 2021, having served as Chief Investment Officer from 2017 to September 2021. He previously served as Chief Executive Officer of Man AHL from 2013 to 2017 and Chief Investment Officer of Man Systematic Strategies from 2010 to 2013. Prior to holding such positions, he held several other senior leadership positions at Man Group. Before joining GLG Partners, which was later acquired by Man Group in 2007, he spent 15 years at Goldman Sachs where he held various positions, including Managing Director and head of the Fundamental Strategy Group. Mr. Rattray also sits on the MSCI Advisory Council. He holds a Master’s Degree in Natural Sciences and Economics from the University of Cambridge and a Licence Spéciale from the Université Libre de Bruxelles. He is also a governor of the Southbank Centre in London.
We believe that Mr. Rattray’s over 25 years of experience in the global investment industry, including his focus on the technological innovation impacting the industry, render him qualified to serve as one of our directors.
Director since: 2007
Age: 61 years old
Audit Committee (Member)
LINDA H. RIEFLER
Ms. Riefler retired from Morgan Stanley in February 2013. Ms. Riefler served as the Chair of Global Research at Morgan Stanley from June 2011 to February 2013 and prior to that served as the Global Head of Research from 2008. She was the Chief Talent Officer of Morgan Stanley from 2006 to 2008. In these roles she served on both the Management Committee and Operating Committee of Morgan Stanley. Ms. Riefler joined Morgan Stanley in 1987 in the Capital Markets division and was appointed a Managing Director in 1998 while in the Research division. Ms. Riefler holds a Bachelor of Arts in economics from Princeton University and an M.B.A. from the Stanford University Graduate School of Business.
CURRENT OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY DIRECTORSHIPS:
CSX Corporation (March 2017 to present)
We believe that Ms. Riefler’s in-depth knowledge of talent management, risk management, company valuation and the global capital markets render her qualified to serve as one of our directors.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||27|
Director since: 2017
Age: 55 years old
Compensation Committee (Member)
MARCUS L. SMITH
Mr. Smith was the Chief Investment Officer, Canada Equity and a Portfolio Manager, International Equities at MFS Investment Management (“MFS”) until his retirement in April 2017. As a portfolio manager, he was responsible for managing the MFS Institutional International Equity Portfolio and the International Concentrated Portfolio. He joined MFS in 1994 and held a variety of positions, including Chief Investment Officer (Asia) from 2010 to 2012, based in Boston, Director of Asian Research from 2005 to 2009, based in Singapore, and Equity Analyst from 1995 to 2000, based in London. Mr. Smith currently also serves as a trustee for certain Eaton Vance funds. Mr. Smith holds a Bachelor of Science from the University of Mount Union and an M.B.A. from the Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania.
CURRENT OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY DIRECTORSHIPS:
First Industrial Realty Trust, Inc. (February 2021 to present)
PRIOR OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY DIRECTORSHIPS:
DCT Industrial Trust, Inc. (October 2017 to August 2018)
We believe that Mr. Smith’s extensive experience in global financial markets and as an investment professional, including experience in Asia and Europe, render him qualified to serve as one of our directors.
Director since: 2021
Age: 57 years old
Audit Committee (Member)
Mr. Taneja is currently the President of Technology for Visa Inc. (“Visa”), a role he has held since September 2019. He joined Visa in November 2013 and served as Executive Vice President of Technology and Operations until August 2019. Prior to joining Visa, Mr. Taneja was Executive Vice President and Chief Technology Officer of Electronic Arts Inc. from October 2011 until November 2013. From August 1996 until October 2011, he served in various roles at Microsoft Corporation (“Microsoft”), including as the Corporate Vice President, Commerce Division. At Microsoft, Mr. Taneja led the development and deployment of commerce and transaction technologies across its connected services, the company’s online digital advertising platforms and its first business online service offering. Mr. Taneja holds a Bachelor of Engineering from Jadavpur University and a Master of Business Administration from Washington State University.
PRIOR OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY DIRECTORSHIPS:
Ellie Mae, Inc. (June 2015 to April 2019)
We believe that Mr. Taneja’s over 30 years of experience in global technology, innovation and research and development render him qualified to serve as one of our directors.
|28||MSCI | PROPOSAL NO. 1: ELECTION OF DIRECTORS|
Director since: 2020
Age: 65 years old
Governance Committee (Member)
Ms. Volent is currently Vice President and Chief Investment Officer at The Rockefeller University, a role she has held since August 2021. She previously served as Senior Vice President for Investments and Chief Investment Officer at Bowdoin College from 2006 to June 2021, Vice President for Investments at Bowdoin College from 2002 to 2006, and Associate Treasurer at Bowdoin College from 2000 to 2002. Prior to joining Bowdoin College in 2000, Ms. Volent served as a Senior Associate at the Yale Investments Office and before focusing on endowment management, she worked as a paper conservator. She holds an M.B.A. from Yale School of Management, a Master of Arts from the Institute of Fine Arts, New York University and a Bachelor of Arts from the University of New Hampshire.
CURRENT OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY DIRECTORSHIPS:
1stdibs.com, Inc. (June 2021 to present)
We believe that Ms. Volent’s experience as a Chief Investment Officer at a number of institutions and her engagement with the global investment community render her qualified to serve as one of our directors.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||29|
MSCI’s Board of Directors adhere to governance principles designed to ensure the continued effectiveness of the Board and excellence in the execution of its duties. The Board has in place a set of governance guidelines reflecting these principles, including the Board’s policy of requiring a significant majority of the Board to be comprised of independent directors; the importance of reflecting a diversity of occupational and personal backgrounds and experience on the Board, including with respect to demographics such as gender, nationality, race, ethnicity, geography and age; and the practice of regularly scheduled executive sessions, including sessions of independent directors without members of management. The MSCI Corporate Governance Policies reflect our principles on corporate governance matters.
MSCI also has a Code of Ethics and Business Conduct for directors, executive officers and employees, which is reviewed annually by the Board of Directors. Any amendment to, or waiver of, the Code of Ethics and Business Conduct that applies to one of our directors or executive officers may be made only by the Board or a Board committee.
Corporate Governance Highlights
|●||All director nominees except our CEO are independent.|
|●||Strong, independent lead director and independent Board committees.|
|●||One share, one vote.|
|●||Annual election of directors.|
|●||Majority vote for uncontested elections and plurality standard for contested elections.|
|●||No shareholder rights plan (i.e., a poison pill).|
|●||Board oversight of corporate responsibility, enterprise risk management and IT/cyber risk.|
|●||Annual Board, committee and director evaluations, with third-party evaluation firm engaged periodically, including in 2019.|
|●||Executive session of independent directors held after each quarterly Board meeting.|
|●||Limits on multiple board service.|
|●||Robust director share ownership and retention guidelines (further enhanced in 2022).|
|●||Annual review of Code of Ethics and Business Conduct, committee charters and Corporate Governance Policies.|
|●||Annual off-season shareholder outreach around corporate responsibility, including regular director participation.|
|●||Full Board participation in succession and progression planning.|
|●||Targeted director education program, including leveraging in-house expertise to educate directors on climate.|
|30||MSCI | CORPORATE GOVERNANCE|
The Governance Committee’s charter requires it to review candidates’ qualifications for membership on the Board or a committee of the Board, including making a specific determination as to the independence of each candidate based on criteria approved by the Board (and taking into account the enhanced independence, financial literacy and financial expertise standards that may be required under applicable law or NYSE rules for audit committee membership purposes, and heightened independence standards that may be required under law or NYSE rules for compensation committee membership purposes). If the Governance Committee determines that adding a new director is advisable, it will recommend such individual to the Board for appointment as a member of the Board and any committees (as applicable).
Consistent with our Corporate Governance Policies, when appointing directors, the Board seeks members who combine sound business judgment, professionalism and a broad spectrum of experience and expertise with a reputation for the highest standards of ethics and integrity. Directors should have experience in positions with a high degree of responsibility, be leaders or senior managers in the companies or institutions with which they are or were affiliated and be selected based upon contributions they can make to the Board and management and their ability to represent and advance the interests of the Company and its shareholders. The Board will also take into account the diversity of a candidate’s perspectives, background and other demographics. Our diversity objectives are also implemented and monitored through periodic reviews by the Governance Committee of the composition of the Board and its committees in light of the then-current challenges and needs of the Board, the Company and each committee, which result in determinations as to whether it may be appropriate to make changes after considering issues of judgment, diversity, age, skills, background and experience. The composition of our current Board demonstrates the Board’s commitment to diversity in a number of areas. Women represent 30% of our current director nominees. Our directors also have differing backgrounds, educations, professional experiences, skills, ages, national origins and viewpoints.
Tenure and Board Refreshment
Our Board has shown an ongoing commitment to Board refreshment and to having highly qualified, independent perspectives in the boardroom. Five of the Company’s director nominees have been added to the Board since the beginning of 2017. The average tenure of the independent director nominees is currently 6.4 years. The average tenure is 7.2 years if Mr. Fernandez is included. Also, under our Corporate Governance Policies, directors should not stand for re-election following their 72nd birthday. Since 2019, two directors have retired following their 72nd birthday and two directors decided not to stand for re-election. These retirements and decisions have provided us with opportunities for Board refreshment.
The Governance Committee also assesses the performance of current directors in its evaluation of current directors for re-nomination to the Board or re-appointment to any Board committees.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||31|
New Director Search Process
Our newest director, Rajat Taneja, was appointed to the Board in 2021. Mr. Taneja has extensive global technology, innovation and research and development experience. His deep knowledge around cybersecurity and risk oversight aligned with the objective of the Audit Committee, to which he was appointed. The appointment of Mr. Taneja was the result of the rigorous search process outlined below.
Our Board is committed to diversity within its membership. The Governance Committee, as part of the search process for any new director, includes women and diverse talent in the pool of candidates and any search firm it engages is instructed to identify a diverse slate of candidates. The Board takes into account diversity of perspectives, background, and other characteristics, including diversity with respect to demographics such as gender, nationality, race, ethnicity, geography and age.
|The Governance Committee, with the feedback of the full Board, identifies key skills that would best serve the future needs of the Board and the Company. Pursuant to the authority granted in its charter, the Governance Committee retains a professional search firm to assist in the process of identifying, evaluating and conducting due diligence on potential director candidates. The Governance Committee instructs the search firm to focus on candidates with relevant industry experience and to seek a diverse slate of candidates. Using a search firm provides additional assurance to the Governance Committee that it is conducting a comprehensive search and evaluating a broad and diverse pool of potential candidates. Additionally, the Governance Committee solicits input from members of management and the Board.|
From the candidates provided by the third-party search firm as well as input from directors and management, the Governance Committee identifies a short list of high-potential candidates, and the search firm then conducts an initial assessment of these candidates’ skills, experience, background and availability to commit to Board service.
The Governance Committee Chair meets with a number of candidates. Certain candidates also meet with members of the Governance Committee, the Chairman and the Lead Director.
|The Governance Committee presents qualified candidates to the Board. In reviewing the potential candidates, the Board takes into account the qualifications discussed in “Director Qualifications” of this Proxy Statement. Following discussion and confirmation of the independence of such candidates, the Board formally appoints candidates to the Board.|
● The Board appointed Rajat Taneja to the Board, effective June 1, 2021.
● Mr. Taneja’s Qualifications:
● Over 30 years of global technology, innovation and research and development experience.
● Leverages his experience to provide invaluable insight into the continuing transformation of MSCI’s data and technology capabilities.
● Prior public company board experience, including service on the Technology and Cybersecurity Committee and Governance and Corporate Responsibility Committee.
In response to shareholder engagement, we amended our Bylaws in 2020 to permit a shareholder, or a group of up to 20 shareholders, owning at least three percent of the Company’s outstanding common stock continuously for at least three years to nominate and include in the Company’s annual meeting proxy materials director nominees constituting the greater of two directors or twenty percent of the total number of directors on the Board, provided that such shareholder(s) and nominee(s) satisfy the requirements specified in the Bylaws.
|32||MSCI | CORPORATE GOVERNANCE|
|Under the MSCI Corporate Governance Policies, the full Board affirmatively determines the independence of directors and reviews the financial and other relationships between the independent directors and MSCI as part of its assessment of director independence. The Governance Committee also makes specific determinations as to the independence of each candidate when reviewing candidates’ qualifications for membership on the Board or a committee of the Board. Director independence is also monitored by the full Board on an ongoing basis.|
Our Corporate Governance Policies provide that the Board should have a significant majority of independent directors meeting the independence requirements of the NYSE. Our Board has determined that each of Messrs. Ashe, Edmunds, Perold, Rattray, Smith, and Taneja and Mmes. Kinney, Riefler and Volent is independent in accordance with the requirements of our Corporate Governance Policies, which follow the NYSE rules and guidelines. In making such determinations, there were no material transactions, relationships or arrangements not disclosed herein under “Other Matters—Certain Transactions” to be considered by the Board in determining whether each director was independent. Therefore, 9 of our 10 current directors are independent. Only Mr. Fernandez is not independent because of his position as CEO of MSCI.
All members of the Audit Committee, Compensation Committee, Governance Committee and Strategy Committee satisfy the independence requirements of the NYSE. In addition, each member of the Audit Committee and Compensation Committee meets the heightened independence standards of the NYSE required for audit committee and compensation committee members, respectively.
The Governance Committee is responsible for the continuing review of the governance structure of the Board, and for recommending to the Board those structures and practices best suited to MSCI and its stockholders. The Governance Committee and the Board recognize that different structures may be appropriate under different circumstances.
We believe that it is in the best interests of MSCI and its shareholders to combine the roles of Chairman and CEO at this time, alongside a robust and independent Lead Director. We believe Mr. Fernandez is best situated to serve as Chairman because he is the director most knowledgeable about the Company’s products, services and industry, and is in a position to effectively identify strategic priorities, recommend appropriate agendas and lead the execution of our strategy. We also believe that combining the role of Chairman and CEO facilitates the flow of information between management and the Board, provides clear accountability and promotes efficient decision making, all of which are essential to effective governance.
A strong, independent Lead Director with clearly defined duties and responsibilities further enhances the contributions of MSCI’s independent directors, which have been and continue to be substantial. Robert G. Ashe has been our Lead Director since April 2018. As Lead Director, Mr. Ashe has significant authority and responsibilities to provide for an effective and independent Board. At the same time, the Company’s other independent directors bring experience, oversight and expertise from various perspectives and disciplines.
|The Board strongly believes that its leadership structure strikes the right balance of allowing our Chairman and CEO to promote a clear, unified vision for the Company’s strategy, providing the leadership critical for effectively and efficiently implementing the actions needed to ensure strong performance over the long term, while ensuring robust, independent oversight by the Board and the Lead Director. The key attributes and responsibilities of the Chairman and the Lead Director roles (which are set forth below) have evolved over time to make MSCI’s leadership both decisive and effective, and to enable the Company to execute on its growth strategies.|
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||33|
|CHAIRMAN AND CEO||LEAD DIRECTOR|
● Unparalleled historical knowledge and depth of understanding of the Company and its businesses
● Oversees the Executive Committee (which includes all of our executive officers) in its day-to-day management of the Company
● Chairs Board meetings and annual shareholder meeting
● Works with the Lead Director to set agendas for Board meetings (which the Lead Director approves)
● Collaborates with the Board on the Company’s strategy and leads management in implementing that strategy
● Meets frequently with clients and shareholders and communicates feedback to the Board and senior management
● Manages the development of senior management and our businesses to succeed in a dynamic and competitive landscape
● Strong and independent leadership style
● Appointed annually by the Board’s independent directors
● Presides at all meetings of the Board at which the Chairman is not present and has the authority to call independent director sessions
● Approves other Board related materials (directors, acting through the Lead Director, may propose matters to be included on the agenda for a meeting)
● Approves Board meeting agendas and schedules to assure sufficient time for discussion of all items
● Facilitates a strong, independent oversight function by leading executive sessions of independent directors at least after every quarterly Board meeting
● Facilitates communication between the Chairman and independent directors
● Leads Board and individual director evaluations
● Meets directly with management other than the CEO and President & COO
● Consults and directly communicates with shareholders and other key constituents, as appropriate
● Collaborates with the Compensation Committee to oversee management succession planning efforts
While we believe that continuing to combine the roles of Chairman and CEO is the most effective leadership structure for our Board and the Company at this time, our Bylaws and Corporate Governance Policies also permit a structure where the CEO would not serve contemporaneously as the Chairman of the Board should the separation of such roles be deemed appropriate and in the best interests of MSCI and its shareholders in the future.
Committees of the Board of Directors
Our Board has adopted a written charter for each of the Audit Committee, Compensation Committee, Governance Committee and Strategy Committee setting forth the roles and responsibilities of each committee. The Board and each committee may, from time-to-time, form and delegate authority to subcommittees when appropriate. Each committee annually reviews and assesses the adequacy of its charter and recommends any proposed changes to the Board for approval. You may access these charters on our website’s Investor Relations homepage (https://ir.msci.com).
The table below provides detail on the composition of each of our designated standing committees as of March 16, 2022.
|Name of Director||Audit
|Henry A. Fernandez(1)|
|Robert G. Ashe|
|Catherine R. Kinney|
|Jacques P. Perold|
|Sandy C. Rattray|
|Linda H. Riefler|
|Marcus L. Smith|
|(1)||Mr. Fernandez is not a formal member of any committee, but he attends most meetings for each committee.||Chair|
|(2)||Mr. Taneja was appointed to the Board and to the Audit Committee on June 1, 2021.||Member|
|34||MSCI | CORPORATE GOVERNANCE|
|AUDIT AND RISK COMMITTEE|
Wayne Edmunds (Chair)
MEETINGS HELD IN 2021: 9
● All members are independent within the meaning of the NYSE standards of independence for directors and audit committee members.
● All members satisfy NYSE financial literacy requirements, each of Messrs. Ashe, Edmunds and Rattray and Ms. Riefler have accounting or other related financial management expertise, and Messrs. Ashe and Edmunds have been designated as “audit committee financial experts,” as defined by SEC rules.
● Oversees the integrity of the Company’s financial statements, internal controls over financial reporting and risk assessment and risk management (including major financial risk exposures and cybersecurity risks).
● Appoints and determines the compensation of the independent auditor.
● Evaluates the qualifications, independence and performance of the independent auditor, including obtaining a report of the independent auditor describing the items set forth in the Audit and Risk Committee’s charter, including those required by the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board.
● Pre-approves audit and permitted non-audit services.
● Reviews and evaluates the audit plan, performance, responsibilities, budget and staffing of the Company’s internal audit function.
● Reviews and discusses with management and the independent auditor the annual audited and quarterly unaudited financial statements included in the Company’s Annual Report on Form 10-K and Quarterly Reports on Form 10-Q, respectively.
● Establishes procedures for (i) the receipt, retention and treatment of complaints regarding accounting, internal accounting controls or auditing matters and (ii) the confidential, anonymous submission by the Company’s employees of concerns regarding questionable accounting or auditing matters, and the review of any submissions received pursuant to such procedures.
● Reviews reports from management relating to the status of compliance with legal and regulatory requirements.
● Reviews with management (i) the Company’s key business risks, including the Company’s major regulatory, litigation and financial risk exposures and technology and cybersecurity risks, (ii) policies and practices with respect to risk governance, risk assessment and risk management, and (iii) the steps that have been taken to assess, monitor and control such risks.
● Reviews the Company’s enterprise risk management program, including its risk governance framework and risk management practices that facilitate the identification, assessment, mitigation and public reporting of risks that may affect the Company.
KEY AREAS OF FOCUS IN 2021:
● Climate risk considerations in light of increasing interest by stakeholders.
● Risks associated with IT and cybersecurity.
● Risk management and governance of data and research used in our ESG and Climate business.
The Audit Committee changed its name in 2021 to the Audit and Risk Committee to provide greater alignment with the full duties and responsibilities outlined in the Audit and Risk Committee’s Charter and reflect the broad scope of its oversight responsibilities.
Further details on the role of the Audit and Risk Committee, as well as the Audit and Risk Committee Report, may be found in “Audit Matters—Audit and Risk Committee Report” on page 97 of this Proxy Statement.
Effective June 1, 2021, Rajat Taneja began serving on the Audit and Risk Committee. Mr. Taneja is independent within the meaning of the NYSE standards of independence for audit committee members and satisfies the NYSE financial literacy requirements.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||35|
COMPENSATION, TALENT AND CULTURE COMMITTEE
Linda H. Riefler (Chair)
MEETINGS HELD IN 2021: 8
● All members are independent within the meaning of the NYSE standards of independence for directors and compensation committee members.
● All members qualify as “non-employee directors” for purposes of Rule 16b-3 under the Exchange Act.
● Reviews the Company’s compensation strategy and reviews and approves the Company’s compensation and benefits policies generally, including reviewing and approving any incentive compensation and equity-based plans of the Company that are subject to Board approval and the Company’s stock ownership guidelines for Executive Committee members.
● Identifies, reviews and approves corporate goals and objectives to be used in the Company’s compensation programs, sets compensation for the Company’s executive officers and such other members of senior management as the Committee determines (the “Executives”), and evaluates each Executive’s performance, each in light of such goals and objectives.
● Reviews and approves the compensation of the Company’s CEO and each of the Company’s other Executives, including: base salary; annual and long-term incentive compensation; employment, severance and change in control agreements; and any other compensation, ongoing perquisites or special benefit items.
● Reviews non-employee director compensation every two years and recommends changes to the Board, when appropriate.
● Periodically reviews, in consultation with the CEO, the Company’s management succession planning and oversees the Company’s talent management, progression planning, career progression and retention strategies and programs, including the Company’s learning and development and DE&I programs.
● At least annually, reviews the Company’s DE&I programs including their key performance metrics.
● Periodically reviews the Company’s initiatives and strategies relating to corporate culture, including considering the Company’s performance and pay-for-performance alignment when reviewing the workplace environment and culture and periodic reviews of the results of the Company’s employee engagement and external surveys.
● Reviews and discusses with management the “Compensation Discussion and Analysis” section of the Company’s annual proxy statement, prepares the Compensation, Talent and Culture Committee Report required by SEC rules and recommends to the Board the inclusion of each in the Company’s annual proxy statement (included on pages 57 and 86 of this Proxy Statement, respectively).
● Reviews and makes recommendations to the Board with respect to the frequency with which the Company will conduct “Say on Pay” votes, taking into account the results of the most recent shareholder advisory vote on frequency of “Say on Pay” votes, if any, and reviews and approves the proposals regarding the “Say on Pay” vote and the frequency of the “Say on Pay” vote to be included in the Company’s proxy statement.
● Considers the independence requirements of the NYSE prior to selecting a compensation consultant, legal counsel or other advisor and evaluates the performance of such advisors and approves all related fees.
● At least annually, reviews and assesses the adequacy of the Company’s Global Human Rights Policy, including any related disclosures, and recommends any proposed changes to the Board, if required.
KEY AREAS OF FOCUS IN 2021:
● In light of the COVID-19 pandemic, received ongoing reports from management around employee well-being, remote work resources and the transition to the Future of Work, our new way of working that provides greater flexibility for a vast majority of our employees.
● Focused on enhancing DE&I initiatives.
● Advised management on linking target annual cash incentives to achievement of individual DE&I goals.
● Focused on MSCI’s organizational design and development to align with an enhanced focus on complete client-centricity.
Compensation Committee Interlocks and Insider Participation: None.
The Compensation and Talent Management Committee changed its name in 2021 to the Compensation, Talent and Culture Committee to provide more clarity and transparency on the committee’s oversight of talent management and corporate culture and reflect the broad scope of its oversight responsibilities.
Benjamin F. duPont ceased serving on the Compensation Committee in connection with his retirement from the Board, effective April 27, 2021.
|36||MSCI | CORPORATE GOVERNANCE|
GOVERNANCE AND CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY COMMITTEE
Jacques P. Perold (Chair)
MEETINGS HELD IN 2021: 5
● All members are independent within the meaning of the NYSE standards of independence for directors.
● Annually reviews the size and composition of the Board and its committees in light of the current challenges and needs of the Board, the Company and each committee and considers the skills, background and experience of each director in doing so.
● Oversees searches for candidates for election to the Board and recommends criteria and individuals for appointment to the Board and its committees. As part of the search process for each new director, focuses on identifying women and other diverse talent in the pool of candidates.
● Retains any search firm that assists the Governance Committee in identifying candidates and maintains sole authority to approve all such search firms’ fees and other retention terms.
● Makes recommendations to the Board as to determinations of director independence.
● Oversees and approves the process and guidelines for the annual evaluation of performance and effectiveness of the Lead Director, the Board and its committees, and individual directors.
● Oversees the Company’s policies and initiatives related to corporate responsibility matters, including environmental stewardship (such as related to climate change) and other sustainability matters. Reviews with Company’s management, including the Chief Responsibility Officer, the Company’s related practices, disclosures, ratings from various providers and risks.
● Evaluates the Company’s shareholder engagement practices and considers feedback received from shareholders.
● At least annually, reviews and assesses the adequacy of the Company’s Corporate Governance Policies and Code of Ethics and Business Conduct and oversees compliance therewith. Reviews with Company’s management, including the Head of Compliance, the Company’s Compliance program, priorities, initiatives, risks and mitigations.
● At least annually, reviews and assesses the adequacy of the Company’s Related Person Transactions Policy and reviews related person transactions pursuant to the Related Person Transactions Policy.
● At least annually, reviews and assesses the adequacy of the Company’s Corporate Political Activities Policy, including any related disclosures, and recommends any proposed changes to the Board, if required.
KEY AREAS OF FOCUS IN 2021:
● On an ongoing basis, reviewed Board composition and Board skills needed, with a focus on enhancing diversity in ongoing director searches and led the director search process resulting in the appointment of one new director in 2021.
● Focused on policies and initiatives related to the Company’s carbon commitments, including the goal of net-zero emissions before 2040.
● Drove enhancements to the Board education program by increasing informal remote- learning sessions for deep-dives on certain areas of the Company’s business, including on ESG and climate.
The Nominating and Corporate Governance Committee changed its name in 2021 to the Governance and Corporate Responsibility Committee to provide more clarity and transparency on the committee’s oversight of corporate responsibility, ESG and climate and other sustainability matters and to reflect the broad scope of its oversight responsibilities.
Mr. duPont ceased serving on the Governance Committee in connection with his retirement from the Board, effective April 27, 2021.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||37|
STRATEGY AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
Robert G. Ashe (Chair)
Jacques P. Perold Sandy C. Rattray
MEETINGS HELD IN 2021: 10
● All members are independent within the meaning of the NYSE standards of independence for directors.
● Evaluates management’s recommendations with respect to the strategic direction of the Company and regularly consults with the Board on the objectives of the Company’s strategic plans and management’s implementation of such plans.
● Reviews and makes recommendations with respect to the agenda for Board strategy meetings with management, taking into account issues important to the full Board.
● Reviews and makes recommendations to the Board with respect to any mergers, combinations, acquisitions, divestitures, joint ventures, minority investments and other strategic investments, and any financings for mergers, acquisitions and other significant financial transactions, in each case requiring the Board’s approval.
● Reviews and oversees management’s plans and objectives for the capitalization of the Company, including target leverage levels and the structure and amount of debt and equity required to meet the Company’s financing needs.
● Oversees the Company’s share repurchase programs, subject to Board-approved policies.
● Reviews and recommends for approval by the Board changes to the Company’s dividend policy.
KEY AREAS OF FOCUS IN 2021:
● Advised management on its capital allocation program, including with respect to its approach to share repurchases, refinancing the Company’s debt and increasing the Company’s quarterly dividend.
● Focused on the competitive landscape and advised management on merger, partnership and acquisition opportunities, with a focus on the private asset segment, including the acquisition of Real Capital Analytics.
● Collaborated with management on the agenda for the Board’s two-day strategy session to ensure alignment with internal investments and growth opportunities.
|38||MSCI | CORPORATE GOVERNANCE|
Attendance at Board Meetings and Annual Meeting of Shareholders
|EACH DIRECTOR ATTENDED AT LEAST|
EXECUTIVE SESSIONS, WHICH FOLLOWED THE BOARD MEETINGS
OCCASIONS WHERE THE BOARD TOOK ACTION BY UNANIMOUS WRITTEN CONSENT
OF THE TOTAL BOARD MEETINGS AND COMMITTEE MEETINGS ON WHICH THE DIRECTOR SERVED THAT WERE HELD WHILE THE DIRECTOR WAS A MEMBER
Our Board met ten times, held independent director executive sessions following all ten of those meetings and took action by unanimous written consent on four occasions during 2021. Each director attended at least 75% of the total meetings of the Board and committees on which the director served that were held while the director was a member.
Discussions between the Board and management on strategic direction, new business opportunities and the scope and mix of the Company’s products were held at each quarterly Board meeting. In addition to formal meetings, members of our Board informally interact with senior management on a periodic basis and participate in informal director education sessions.
Our Corporate Governance Policies state that directors are expected to attend the annual meetings of shareholders. In 2021, all of our directors who were on the Board at the time attended our annual meeting of shareholders.
Independent Director Meetings
Our Corporate Governance Policies provide that our Lead Director will preside over non-employee director sessions. The Lead Director presided over ten independent director sessions during 2021. The Board’s standing committees also have a practice of holding executive sessions after their quarterly meetings. Our Corporate Governance Policies further provide that if any non-employee directors are not independent, then the independent directors will meet at least once a year in an independent director session and the Lead Director will preside over each such independent director session. During 2021, all non-employee directors were independent.
Director Education and Orientation Program
Directors are encouraged and provided with opportunities to attend educational sessions on subjects that can assist them in performing their duties. Pursuant to the Director Education Policy, the Company will reimburse directors for reasonable costs incurred from attending these sessions. In addition to external educational opportunities, directors participate in educational sessions, including product line reviews presented by the heads of our product lines. Directors also participate in an annual review of leading corporate governance practices by corporate governance experts, briefing sessions on topics that present special risks and opportunities and updates on accounting topics. The Company is also part of a peer-engaged program designed to enhance director performance, and we leverage virtual platforms to provide deep dive sessions on certain aspects of MSCI’s business outside of quarterly meetings. In 2021, the Board held virtual learning sessions on, among other things, climate change science, climate investments, net-zero commitments, our go-to-market strategy and our data and technology strategy. In 2022 and following a return to in-person meetings, these virtual sessions are expected to continue and will be used to further educate the Board on, among other things, climate-related risks and opportunities and DE&I initiatives.
All new directors participate in a director orientation program that includes briefings by senior management representing the heads of product lines and key functional areas on topics that include, among others, the Company’s strategic plans, capital structure, product overviews, historical financial performance and key policies and practices, including compliance and trading policies. New directors are also encouraged to attend all committee meetings during their first year on the Board. In 2021, Mr. Taneja joined the Board while the Company was still in a remote working environment. His director orientation program was conducted virtually, which allowed for more streamlined sessions with increased global participation by senior management.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||39|
Board and Individual Director Evaluations
In addition to the ongoing assessment of the functioning of the Board, each year, our directors formally evaluate the effectiveness of the Board and its committees through a self-assessment administered by our directors and management. Directors respond to questions designed to elicit information that will be useful in improving Board and committee effectiveness. Such feedback is discussed during executive session and, where appropriate, addressed with management. The process for this annual feedback is set forth below.
INITIATION OF PROCESS
|The members of the Governance Committee provide their thoughts on the factors to be used in evaluating the Board, its committees and individual directors. The Corporate Secretary prepares a director self-assessment questionnaire based on these factors. In 2021, MSCI’s Chief Diversity Officer also reviewed and provided updates to the questionnaire to ensure that it properly reflected the importance of DE&I considerations. The Governance Committee also oversees and approves the process and guidelines for the annual evaluation of the performance and effectiveness of the Lead Director.|
|Each director then completes an anonymous self-assessment questionnaire covering a range of topics, including structure, culture, and roles of the Board and its committees. The Lead Director also conducts individual director evaluations through interviews with each director on an annual basis.|
|The Corporate Secretary compiles the quantitative and qualitative data from the questionnaires and consults with the Lead Director and the Chair of the Governance Committee on the results. The Lead Director and Chair of the Governance Committee review the results with the full Board in executive session.|
|The Lead Director and Chair of the Governance Committee then discuss with the management the feedback provided by the Board and any enhancements in practices that may be warranted.|
ENHANCED REVIEW OF STRATEGIC GOALS:
● Periodic review with Board on strategic initiatives
● Board and committee agendas increasingly focus on “forward-looking” topics
INCREASED FOCUS ON ESG AND CLIMATE:
● Governance Committee assigned responsibility for ESG and climate oversight
● Chief Responsibility Officer provides quarterly reports to the Governance Committee
● DE&I goals required for all Managing Directors, and tied to individual compensation
● For Executive Committee members, climate commitment goals added to KPI goals
ENHANCED DIRECTOR EDUCATION PROGRAM:
● Joined peer-engaged program designed to enhance director performance
● Leveraged virtual platforms to provide deep- dive sessions on certain aspects of MSCI’s business outside of quarterly meetings, including climate
SUCCESSION PLANNING AND TALENT MANAGEMENT:
● President & COO meets quarterly in executive session with independent directors
● Potential successors to senior management invited to speak at Board meetings for additional exposure
● Succession planning at levels beyond the Executive Committee; accelerated development of current internal candidates at all levels
|40||MSCI | CORPORATE GOVERNANCE|
The Board may also periodically engage a third-party evaluation firm as part of this process. In 2019, a third-party evaluation firm met with certain members of senior management and members of the Board. The feedback from the third-party evaluation firm was considered by the Board and, where appropriate, the Board recommended enhancements to its practices based on such feedback.
|By the Numbers: Shareholder Engagement in 2021|
|WE HELD OVER 300 MEETINGS with our shareholders, prospective shareholders and sell-side analysts, during which we MET WITH SHAREHOLDERS REPRESENTING ~58% OF OUR SHARES OUTSTANDING, with participation at certain meetings by our CEO, President & COO, CFO, Head of Investor Relations, Chief Responsibility Officer and other members of senior management||10 INVESTOR CONFERENCES AND 8 NON-DEAL ROADSHOWS AND ANALYST SPONSORED EVENTS to discuss topics including long-term growth opportunities, strategic execution, financial performance, capital allocation and corporate responsibility|
|SUCCESSFUL INVESTOR DAY which highlighted the achievement of our financial performance over the last several years, as well as provided a deeper understanding of our key strategic initiatives and an update on our long-term financial outlook||REWARDING CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY ROADSHOW where we met with our top shareholders representing more than 40% of our outstanding shares to discuss our corporate responsibility practices|
We believe that engaging with our shareholders, prospective shareholders and sell-side analysts is the best way to address the issues that matter most to them. Dialogue with these constituencies helps us understand their perspectives on the Company’s goals and expectations for performance, as well as identify issues that might affect our long-term strategy, corporate governance and compensation practices. As such, we offer several opportunities to provide feedback to our Board and senior management, including inviting certain shareholders to address the Board to present their views on the Company.
Our Investor Relations team leads year-round outreach efforts with our investors and the investment community. During these engagements, we typically discuss topics such as market trends affecting our industry, the competitive environment, our go-to-market strategy, our financial performance and our overall outlook for the Company. In February 2021, we hosted an Investor Day to reiterate our growth opportunities and share management’s strategy for taking advantage of those opportunities.
We also engage with shareholders before, during and after the proxy season, including by hosting a Corporate Responsibility Roadshow each winter, to review and receive feedback on the Company’s governance practices, our corporate responsibility efforts and human capital management strategies and the design of our executive compensation program. The feedback we receive from these discussions, as well as from third-party rating agencies, is carefully considered by the Board, the Governance Committee and the Compensation Committee.
During the Corporate Responsibility Roadshow that we hosted in the winter of 2021, our shareholders focused the discussions on, among other things, the following: (i) our corporate responsibility practices and disclosures in light of being a leader in ESG ratings and data and our path to Net-Zero and climate initiatives, (ii) human capital management, including the importance of efforts around DE&I, (iii) talent management and executive and director succession planning and (iv) Board oversight and governance, including over our corporate responsibility efforts. These meetings often included a member of our Governance Committee as well as our Head of Investor Relations, Chief Responsibility Officer, Head of Corporate Responsibility, Chief Diversity Officer, Corporate Secretary, Head of Employer Brand and Talent Pipelines and Global Head of Compensation and Benefits.
Additional information on our recent actions in response to investor feedback can be found under Corporate Responsibility on page 12 and beginning on page 45 of this Proxy Statement. Please see page 66 of this Proxy Statement for additional information on our engagement efforts specific to compensation matters.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||41|
Risk Assessment Responsibilities and Processes
Our Board discusses and receives regular updates on a wide variety of matters affecting our firm. Our Board is responsible for, and committed to, the oversight of the business and affairs of our firm. In carrying out this responsibility, the Board’s role in risk oversight is consistent with the Company’s leadership structure, with management having day-to-day responsibility for identifying, evaluating and managing the Company’s risk exposure and the Board having the ultimate responsibility for overseeing risk management governance, with a focus on the Company’s most significant risks. In this role, the Board is responsible for ensuring that the risk-management processes designed and implemented by management are functioning as intended and that necessary steps are taken to assess, monitor and control key business risks.
In order to maintain effective Board oversight across the entire firm, the Board delegates to individual committees certain elements of its oversight function, as described in the example below. The Board then receives regular updates from its committees on individual categories of risk, including strategy, reputation, operations, climate change, corporate responsibility, people, technology and regulatory. Our Board’s focus on overseeing risk management also enhances our directors’ ability to provide insight and feedback to senior management.
The Board is assisted in meeting its risk oversight responsibilities by its committees as described below. The below illustration uses climate-related risks as an example of our risk oversight responsibilities and processes.
|42||MSCI | CORPORATE GOVERNANCE|
Board Oversight: The Climate Example
Board of Directors
Oversees Major Risks
On an ongoing basis, receives quarterly written reports on enterprise-level risks, including climate-related risks.
Receives regular reports from each of the Board’s committees on their areas of risk oversight including, from time-to-time, climate-related risks.
● Receives quarterly updates from our Enterprise Risk Management Officer, which, in 2021, included a review of the governance and risks of ESG data integrity, as well as of opportunities related to reducing the Company's carbon footprint.
● Receives quarterly updates from our Chief Information Security Officer on our business continuity plans and IT disaster recovery efforts to mitigate the impact of potential disruptions, including those that could be caused by climate and extreme weather events.
● Oversees the Company’s assessment of executive performance against goals, including ESG and climate related goals.
● Oversees talent management, including talent acquisition and succession planning relating to leaders in our ESG and climate business.
● Ensures that management factors material climate-related risks and opportunities into the Company’s strategy.
● Monitors and provides guidance on strategic objectives, including on sustainability-related mergers, partnerships and acquisition opportunities such as for those related to climate-related products and services.
● Oversees the Company’s corporate responsibility policies and initiatives, including ESG and climate initiatives.
● Receives quarterly updates from the Chief Responsibility Officer. In 2021, these focused on MSCI’s net-zero commitment, climate-related initiatives and Corporate Responsibility Operating Plan.
● Members of the Governance Committee participate in the annual Corporate Responsibility Roadshow to hear and report back to the Board on shareholders’ priorities, including climate-related risks and opportunities.
● Periodically reviews with management requests from shareholders and the investment community for climate-related disclosures.
● Our management team has day-to-day responsibility for identifying, assessing and managing ESG and climate-related risks and opportunities. The Company’s Enterprise Risk Oversight Committee oversees the Company’s key risk management activities to ensure that the Company is identifying, evaluating and managing risks that may have an impact on the Company’s ability to achieve its operational and strategic objectives, including ongoing assessments of climate risks.
● The Business Resiliency team assesses the severity, probability and scale of climate-related events, and implements and tests technology systems to support our business continuity plans.
● Our Crisis Management Team and Technology Service Operations Management Team oversee all aspects of our disaster and recovery response efforts, including protecting the general welfare and safety of our employees, data centers, networks, applications supporting business operations, communications systems and general technology recovery following an extreme weather incident or natural disaster. Our Internal Audit Team periodically reviews various aspects of these programs to provide independent assessment and assurance to management and the Board.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||43|
Cybersecurity and Information Security Awareness
Our Board recognizes that the security of our technology is integral to our products, our business processes and our infrastructure. The mission of our management-level Information and Technology Risk Oversight Committee (“ITROC”), led by our Chief Information Security Officer (“CISO”), is to provide oversight relating to cyber security- and technology-related risks that may present significant impact to our operations, clients, reputation and financial position. Our IT risk program also includes an incident response plan that provides controls and procedures for timely and accurate reporting of any material cybersecurity incident, on-going internal and external assessments of our IT controls and security awareness training for employees.
On a quarterly basis, the Audit Committee is updated on the Company’s IT risk program by our CISO, including an overview of risks and trends, that is also made available to the full Board. In addition, the Audit Committee receives updates about the results of assessments conducted by outside advisors who provide independent assessments of our IT risk program and our response preparedness. The Chair of the Audit Committee informs the Board of any key updates during his quarterly reports to the Board.
Enterprise Risk Awareness
Our approach to overseeing new and emerging risks across MSCI is informed by our management-level Enterprise Risk Oversight Committee (“EROC”), chaired by our Chief Financial Officer. The EROC provides oversight of MSCI’s risk management activities to ensure that we are identifying, evaluating and managing risks that may have an adverse impact on our ability to achieve operational and strategic objectives. The enterprise risk management program currently evaluates risk in numerous areas within MSCI, including technology infrastructure; clients; people, including talent management and DE&I; financial resilience; legal, regulatory and compliance; and corporate responsibility, including areas such as climate risk. Within each category, we seek to identify and mitigate risks, enable improved decision-making and prioritization, and promote monitoring and reporting across functions within the Company. While the EROC captures and monitors risk management activities regarding our IT security and technology infrastructure, primary reporting and evaluation of risks relating to our technology infrastructure sits with the ITROC, as detailed above.
On a quarterly basis, the Audit Committee is updated on MSCI’s enterprise risk management program by our Enterprise Risk Management Officer, including an overview of risks and trends, that is also made available to the full Board. Quarterly presentations to the Audit Committee include more detailed discussions of emerging topics and trends. In 2021, these discussions included topics such as ESG and climate-related risks and opportunities as well as MSCI’s regulatory environment. The Chair of the Audit Committee informs the Board of any key updates during his quarterly reports to the Board.
Integrated with our IT security program and our enterprise risk program is our global privacy program. Our privacy program is led by our Chief Privacy Officer and the members of the MSCI Privacy Office, and it reports into our CISO. Our Privacy Steering Committee meets on a quarterly basis to review key risks and trends, progress on key initiatives, focus topics and regulatory developments. The Privacy Steering Committee is an essential component of our efforts to safeguard the processing of personal, sensitive and confidential data at MSCI and provides cross-functional oversight of our privacy program.
|44||MSCI | CORPORATE GOVERNANCE|
Management Succession Planning
One of the Board’s principal responsibilities is to ensure appropriate succession plans are in place for our senior management and review our executive talent including our potential leadership bench. The Compensation Committee oversees the process for succession planning for senior management positions. Our CEO and President & COO also meet regularly with our functions to review talent plans with an aim to identify top talent, including diverse talent, who have the most potential to progress to the senior-most roles at MSCI.
In January 2022, as part of these efforts and following an extensive organizational design assessment conducted in 2021, we announced a number of organizational and senior leadership changes, and we expanded our Executive Committee to reflect MSCI’s ambition to serve as an indispensable partner to clients and the investment community. This expansion brings together and elevates more of the senior leaders who drive MSCI’s strategy and operations into MSCI’s primary leadership committee. The new members of the Executive Committee increase the representation from operating functions, in particular, Research, Technology and Data, and Private Assets. Additional information on our Executive Committee can be found on the “Our Leadership” section of our website (https://www.msci.com/who-we-are/our-leadership).
|DEVELOPING OUR NEXT GENERATION OF LEADERS|
|High-potential leaders are given exposure to our directors through formal presentations at Board or committee meetings, informal virtual education sessions, one-on-one meetings with individual directors and participation in other Board activities.|
|FORMAL SUCCESSION PLANNING|
|Annual formal succession planning and talent review session held by the Compensation Committee, where all directors are invited to attend.|
|This session includes identifying successors and reviewing succession plans for all senior management positions, including the CEO and President positions.|
|The Board holds ongoing reviews of our leadership bench.|
Over the last year, the Company made the following examples of senior management appointments from its succession pools:
|●||Former Head of Japan Client Coverage promoted to Head of APAC Client Coverage and Head of APAC Analytics following predecessor’s departure|
|●||Former Head of ESG and Climate promoted to Chief Product Officer and Head of Index|
|●||Former Head of ESG Products promoted to Head of ESG and Climate|
|●||Former Head of Americas Index Client Coverage promoted to Head of Client Coverage – Americas|
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||45|
As a leader in providing ESG and climate solutions to investors, we also aim to demonstrate leading corporate responsibility practices and policies that are meaningful to our various stakeholders, including our shareholders, clients, employees and local communities. This commitment includes our response to climate change and how we promote DE&I in our workforce.
Our commitment to corporate responsibility is embodied in four pillars: Better Investments for a Better World, Sustainable Operations, Social Responsibility, and Robust Governance:
|46||MSCI | CORPORATE GOVERNANCE|
Focus on Climate: Key Highlights
We take our commitment to climate seriously. As a leader in ESG and climate research and applications, MSCI is also committed to do its part to address climate change. We are focused on reducing our carbon footprint and ensuring our approach is well-aligned with our tools and solutions. Some of our recent areas of progress on our Company’s climate considerations include the ones detailed below.
New Commitments & Policies
● Announced our commitment to the goal of Net-Zero emissions by 2040
● Became a founding member of the Net Zero Financial Service Provider Alliance
● Announced our commitment to support the UN SDGs and published a report demonstrating our contribution to four SDGs, using metrics aligned with our proprietary methodology to assess the SDG alignment of corporates
● Updated our Environmental Policy to include our net-zero commitment
● Updated our Supplier Code of Conduct to address emissions in MSCI’s supply chain
● Updated our Travel Policy to prioritize virtual meetings and the use of low carbon travel options
● Developed an internal Sustainable Supplier Management Team to support our efforts to learn about our suppliers’ corporate responsibility practices and through engagement, seek to align them with our own climate commitments
● Enhanced our risk management framework to include reporting on climate considerations
● Enhanced our corporate responsibility governance by creating a Corporate Responsibility Policy Committee
● Conducted Board education sessions on climate
● Brought together corporates, pensions and asset managers in roundtables to discuss climate trends and corporate responsibility practices
● Developed easy-to-access webpage dedicated to Sustainability Reports & Policies, including:
● UN SDG Report
● Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) Report
● Third CDP report, with an improved grade of A-
● SASB guide
● Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) Report
● Fifth UN PRI questionnaire
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||47|
Corporate Responsibility Governance
We ensure the robustness of oversight over our corporate responsibility efforts through our governance process. Through a well-established framework and cross-functional committee structure, with leaders from across the organization, MSCI incorporates corporate responsibility into its core strategy—reflecting our belief that sustainable practices are essential to long-term growth. In line with this focus, the Governance Committee oversees the company’s significant corporate responsibility matters, including corporate responsibility priorities and disclosure, with management having day-to-day responsibility over these efforts.
In 2021, we enhanced our corporate responsibility governance by separating our CRC, which reviews corporate responsibility issues and policy proposals, from the newly created CRPC, a smaller group of Executive Committee members who review strategically significant proposals regarding corporate responsibility policies, actions and disclosures.
Second, we expanded the CRC, which reports to the CRPC. The CRC meets on a monthly basis and reviews corporate responsibility trends, shares updates on the implementation of MSCI’s Corporate Responsibility Operating Plan and reviews MSCI’s corporate responsibility reports. The CRC also considers corporate responsibility initiatives and makes recommendations to the CRPC on the most strategic ones.
To underscore our commitment to our corporate responsibility efforts, in 2022, our Chief Responsibility Officer relinquished her role as Head of Index to become fully dedicated to corporate responsibility.
Our Corporate Responsibility Oversight Framework
Our Chief Responsibility Officer leads the CRPC, where she presents to MSCI’s key decision makers and/or internal experts on corporate responsibility-related actions that may ultimately be recommended to our CEO, President & COO and/or the Board. As a member of the Executive Committee, she also brings corporate responsibility considerations to senior leadership discussions on MSCI’s business strategy and operations. At the Board level, she provides written updates to the Governance Committee in advance of each quarterly meeting on MSCI’s corporate responsibility efforts. The full Board also has access to these updates. In addition, at least twice per year, she presents to the Governance Committee on key initiatives and management’s performance against our Corporate Responsibility Operating Plan. In 2021, the Corporate Responsibility Operating Plan was largely informed by feedback from our stakeholders to increase our transparency in areas such as climate and DE&I. Key developments are shared with the full Board during the Governance Committee’s quarterly report to the Board.
The Head of Corporate Responsibility was appointed in 2021 and reports to the Chief Responsibility Officer. She leads our officer-level CRC in its efforts to broaden the scope of perspectives that review the Company’s corporate responsibility actions.
|48||MSCI | CORPORATE GOVERNANCE|
The Board’s Oversight of Corporate Responsibility
|Board of Directors|
Governance and Corporate Responsibility Committee
Compensation, Talent and Culture Committee
Audit & Risk Committee
Strategy & Finance Committee
● Chief Responsibility Officer* provides quarterly updates
● Corporate Secretary+ manages annual review of charters and Board policies
● Head of Compliance provides annual update
● External Counsel leads annual governance review
● Governance Committee oversees shareholder engagement on corporate responsibility matters, including participation by its members in annual Corporate Responsibility Roadshow
● Chief Human Resources Officer* oversees quarterly meetings and succession and progression planning updates
● Chief Diversity Officer+ provides updates on DE&I initiatives and strategic enhancements
● Head of Compensation & Benefits incorporates the Compensation Committee’s recommendations into executive compensation program
● Compensation Consultant advises Compensation Committee on risk assessment and peer and best practices
● CFO* and Global Controller+ oversee quarterly meetings
● Independent Auditor oversees integrity in financial reporting
● Internal Auditor reports to Audit Committee and provides quarterly updates on audit activities, findings and assurance
● Enterprise Risk Management Officer and Chief Information Security Officer+ provide quarterly reports
● CFO* oversees quarterly meetings
● CFO* partners with Strategy Committee to develop agenda for annual strategy meeting
● Heads of Product Lines*+ present strategy at annual strategy meeting
|*||Member of Corporate Responsibility Policy Committee|
|+||Member of or function represented on Corporate Responsibility Committee|
Risk Oversight of Corporate Responsibility
MSCI’s EROC is also integrated into our corporate responsibility oversight framework. The EROC oversees MSCI’s risk-management governance to ensure that MSCI has an effective process designed to identify, evaluate and manage risks that may have an adverse impact on MSCI’s ability to achieve its operational and strategic objectives. Climate-related risks are integrated into MSCI risk reporting, including transition and physical climate risks. The Audit Committee receives a quarterly update from the Enterprise Risk Management Officer on the work of the EROC, which includes reporting on climate-related risks.
Additional information on our corporate responsibility efforts, including our published sustainability reports, can be found on our Corporate Responsibility website (https://www.msci.com/who-we-are/corporate-responsibility).
We recognize that our people power our business and that our diverse workforce and inclusive work environment are critical to our success. Our Compensation Committee’s oversight responsibilities include our policies relating to DE&I, corporate culture and employee engagement. The Compensation Committee at least annually receives updates on the Company’s progress on DE&I initiatives, including key performance metrics, and the Chief Diversity Officer regularly presents to the Compensation Committee. The Compensation Committee also annually reviews MSCI’s Global Human Rights Policy and related disclosures.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||49|
|Learning and Development||Diversity, Equity and Inclusion||Health and Safety and Future of Work|
● We are committed to creating a performance and growth culture of high employee engagement, where every employee takes personal ownership of their performance, career and professional growth
● We offer tools and workshops to help employees better understand how their work aligns with our overall strategy, seek and receive feedback and coaching, successfully deliver on goals and plan and develop their careers. Recent updates include:
● 210%+(1) increase in our investment in learning and development since 2015
● 5x(1) growth in the number of participants in our learning and development programs from 2017 to 2021
● We support employee learning by sponsoring and reimbursing employees for certain certifications and membership dues, ongoing education and relevant industry conferences and seminars
● Additional examples of programs offered include:
● Virtual training programs to build remote capabilities
● Mystery Coffee: connects employees across the globe for informal networking opportunities
● Career Success at MSCI: enables employees to plan, manage and take actions aligned with their career aspirations
● Accelerated Leadership Development: provides one-on-one coaching, leadership skills development, networking and applied learning
● Women’s Sponsorship/Mentorship program for high performing women
● Integration programs for new colleagues from Real Capital Analytics
● Our people are empowered to maximize their potential in an environment where all individuals are respected and encouraged to bring their authentic selves to work
● In May 2021, we appointed our first Chief Diversity Officer
● Continued sponsorship of existing ERGs, with three new ERGs launched in 2021: Asian Support Network, All Abilities Network and Hola! MSCI
● Linked 10% of target annual cash incentive under AIP program to DE&I Goals for all Managing Directors, and created an Executive Accountability Framework to establish the philosophy and process for assessing progress against DE&I Goals
● Executed 4th Annual Global DE&I Summit, focusing on leadership development and strategic planning
● Continued partnerships with multiple external resources for our outreach and engagement with diverse talent, including #10,000 Black Interns and Rare Recruitment
● Launched an inclusive internship program in New York, London and Chicago for undergraduates and masters students, sourced from partnership organizations and key universities globally
● An employee engagement check-in survey in December 2021 showed that 91% of respondents are proud to work at MSCI and 87% feel they can bring their authentic selves to work(1)
● We have a long-standing commitment to the health, safety and well-being of our employees
● Early in the course of the COVID-19 pandemic, we prioritized the well-being of our global workforce by having the vast majority of our employees work from home
● At the onset of the pandemic, we engaged a firm of global medical and safety experts to provide additional information and guidance to all of our offices globally
● We have increased communications about employee assistance programs that provide mental health and emotional well-being support, as well as resources to help manage stress and care for individuals and their families
● In January 2022, we transitioned to our Future of Work at MSCI, which introduced increased flexibility to how and where employees work, reimagined our use of our offices, and modernized technology to enhance MSCI’s interactions with clients and employees
● To protect the health and safety of our employees, we implemented a global vaccination policy requiring employees and visitors to be fully vaccinated prior to entering an MSCI office or participating in an MSCI-sponsored function.
● Our Global Human Rights Policy reflects our commitment to a safe, inclusive and diverse workplace, and is annually reviewed by the Compensation Committee
|(1)||On September 13, 2021, we completed our acquisition of Real Capital Analytics, a provider of data and analytics for the properties and transactions that drive the global commercial real estate capital markets. This information does not reflect or include these new employees from Real Capital Analytics.|
|TOTAL EMPLOYEES: GENDER(1)(2)||U.S. EMPLOYEES: RACE/ETHNICITY(1)(3)|
|(1)||Data as of December 31, 2021.|
|(2)||3% of global employees have not identified gender and are not included in the data calculations.|
|(3)||11% of U.S. employees have not identified race/ethnicity and are not included in the data calculations.|
|50||MSCI | CORPORATE GOVERNANCE|
Compensation, Talent and Culture Governance
The Compensation Committee operates under a written charter adopted by the Board. To provide more clarity and transparency to investors and stakeholders on Board committee-level oversight of talent management, in 2021, the Board changed the name of its Compensation & Talent Management Committee to “Compensation, Talent and Culture Committee.” This corresponds with changes to the Compensation Committee’s charter in 2021 to reflect more direct oversight of talent management, including talent acquisition, development and career progression, as well as the Company’s policies relating to DE&I, corporate culture and employee engagement. As noted above in the description of the Compensation Committee’s responsibilities, the Compensation Committee is responsible for reviewing and approving annually all compensation awarded to the Company’s Executives, including the CEO and our other NEOs.
The Compensation Committee also regularly engages with our CEO, President & COO, Chief Human Resources Officer, Chief Diversity Officer and other members of senior leadership on a broad range of human capital management topics. The Board regularly receives reports from the Compensation Committee on human capital management topics throughout the year. The Compensation Committee annually reviews the Company’s talent management strategies and programs with respect to senior levels in the organization, including the Company’s DE&I strategies and programs and key performance metrics, and periodically reviews open senior management roles, future talent needs, the Company’s corporate culture and learning and development programs, as well as the results of the Company’s employee engagement survey. See page 35 of this Proxy Statement for additional information on the Compensation Committee’s responsibilities.
The principal compensation plans and arrangements applicable to our NEOs are described in the “Compensation Matters” section of this Proxy Statement and the executive compensation tables included therein. The Compensation Committee may delegate the administration of these plans and arrangements, as appropriate, including to one or more officers of the Company, subcommittees or to the Chair of the Compensation Committee, in each case, when it deems doing so to be appropriate, in the best interests of the Company and consistent with applicable law and NYSE requirements.
The Compensation Committee has the authority to retain and terminate any compensation consultant assisting the Compensation Committee in the evaluation of CEO or other executive officer compensation. As further described in the “Compensation Discussion and Analysis” section included herein, during 2021, the Compensation Committee continued to retain Semler Brossy Consulting Group, LLC (“Semler Brossy”) as its own independent compensation consultant to review CEO and other executive officer compensation. All of the services provided by Semler Brossy to the Compensation Committee during 2021 were to provide advice or recommendations on the amount or form of executive officer and director compensation, and Semler Brossy did not provide any additional services to the Company during 2021. The Compensation Committee has considered, among other things, the factors delineated in Rule 10C-1 under the Exchange Act (“Rule 10C-1”), including the NYSE listing rules implementing Rule 10C-1 and Semler Brossy’s conflict of interest policies, and determined that the engagement of Semler Brossy does not raise any conflict of interest or other factors that compromise the independence of its relationship with the Compensation Committee. In developing its views on compensation matters and determining the compensation awarded to our CEO and other executive officers, the human resources department provides data and analyses to aid the Compensation Committee in its decisions. The CEO also makes recommendations on compensation for executive officers other than himself and the Compensation Committee takes these recommendations into account in reaching its compensation decisions. From time to time, the Compensation Committee may obtain input from external legal counsel, including Davis Polk & Wardwell LLP (“Davis Polk”), on compensation award documentation and other compensation-related practices, which in 2021 was communicated to the Compensation Committee via management, the legal department or the human resources department. In light of this relationship, the Compensation Committee has considered, among other things, the factors delineated in Rule 10C-1, including the NYSE listing rules implementing Rule 10C-1 and Davis Polk’s conflict of interest policies.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||51|
Director Compensation Best Practices
|Robust Director Stock Ownership Guidelines||Each non-employee director is required to own a target number of shares of stock of the Company equal to the sum of the “net shares” resulting from the vesting of the RSUs granted to such director for each of the last five years.|
|Anti-Hedging and Anti-Pledging Policy||We prohibit all directors and employees, including all NEOs, from hedging or pledging the Company’s common stock or engaging in short sales, purchases or sales of options, puts or calls, as well as derivatives such as swaps, forwards or futures and trading on a short-term basis in the Company’s common stock.|
|Emphasis on Equity Compensation||The most significant portion of non-employee director compensation is the annual RSU equity award for service on the Board.|
Director Compensation Program
The Compensation Committee reviews non-employee director compensation every two years and recommends changes, when appropriate, to the Board. The Compensation Committee is aided in its review by its external independent compensation consultant, Semler Brossy. The Compensation Committee takes into account peer benchmarking and broader general industry practices to establish non-employee director compensation.
|DIRECTOR FEES||COMMITTEE MEMBERSHIP FEES|
|*||Based on the closing price of our common stock as reported by the NYSE on the trading day prior to grant.|
|Effective May 1, 2022, the cash retainer for serving as chair of the Governance Committee will increase by $5,000 to $25,000, for parity with the chair role of a number of our other committees. In addition, the grant date values of the annual RSU equity awards for each non-employee director will increase by $20,000 to $185,000 and for the Lead Director will increase to $235,000, following a review of peer company and market practice.|
Directors may elect under the terms of the MSCI Inc. 2016 Non-Employee Directors Compensation Plan (the “Directors Plan”) to receive their cash retainer in the form of shares of our common stock. Under the Directors Plan, non-employee directors are subject to annual limits on their cash and equity compensation, which were approved by our shareholders at our 2016 annual meeting of shareholders, as follows: non-employee directors may not receive in any calendar year (i) options, restricted stock, RSUs and other stock-based awards with a grant date fair value of more than $1,000,000 (as determined in accordance with
|52||MSCI | DIRECTOR COMPENSATION AND STOCK OWNERSHIP GUIDELINES|
applicable accounting standards) and (ii) retainers and other cash-based awards in excess of $1,000,000. These caps cannot be increased without the approval of our shareholders.
RSUs granted to non-employee directors are granted on May 1st of each year and vest on the first anniversary of the grant date. Cash retainers and RSU awards are prorated when a director joins the Board and/or a committee at any time other than May 1st. RSUs granted on or after May 1st vest on the next May 1st to occur following the grant date. For example, if a director joins the Board on February 1, 2022, his or her prorated RSUs will vest on May 1, 2022. If a director joins the Board on May 31, 2022, his or her prorated RSUs will vest on May 1, 2023.
RSUs are recognized as an expense in the Company’s financial statements for financial reporting purposes with respect to 2021 in accordance with FASB ASC Subtopic 718-10.
Holders of these RSUs are entitled to participate in dividend equivalent payments, and such payments may be settled in cash, shares of our common stock, or a combination thereof, to be decided by the Company in its sole discretion. Prior to the conversion to shares, RSU holders do not have any rights as an MSCI shareholder with respect to such RSUs, including the right to vote the underlying shares. The RSUs are generally non-transferable; however, our Board may, in its discretion, specify circumstances under which an award may become immediately transferable and nonforfeitable or under which the award will be forfeited. The RSUs vest and convert to shares immediately upon termination of service for reasons of death, disability or a change in control. If service as a director terminates for any other reason, all unvested RSUs will be cancelled and forfeited unless determined otherwise by the Board or the Compensation Committee.
Non-employee directors are reimbursed for expenses incurred in connection with attending Board meetings and educational sessions.
Director Deferral Plan
Under the MSCI Inc. Non-Employee Directors Deferral Plan (the “Deferral Plan”), our directors are permitted to defer receipt of shares of our common stock payable in lieu of cash retainers and/or upon conversion of RSUs granted to the director following the year for which an election has been submitted; provided that an election made by a director within 30 days after the director becomes eligible to receive a cash retainer or RSUs shall apply to any common stock payable in lieu of such a cash retainer and/or upon conversion of such RSUs granted to the director following the date on which the director makes the election. Receipt of shares of our common stock may be deferred until a future date specified by the director, a separation from service (as defined by Treasury regulations), or the earlier of the two. While the Deferral Plan allows for it, the Board has not yet implemented a process for the deferral of cash payments.
2021 Non-Employee Director Compensation
|Name||Fees Earned or
Paid in Cash(1)(2)
|Robert G. Ashe||114,642||214,710||1,777||331,129|
|Benjamin F. duPont(6)||—||—||9,159||9,159|
|Catherine R. Kinney||89,867||164,676||75,468||330,011|
|Jacques P. Perold||110,000||164,676||1,363||276,039|
|Sandy C. Rattray||100,000||164,676||1,363||266,039|
|Linda H. Riefler||115,000||164,676||1,363||281,039|
|Marcus L. Smith||100,000||164,676||1,363||266,039|
|(1)||Pursuant to MSCI’s Third Amended and Restated Articles of Incorporation, directors hold office for a term expiring at the next annual meeting of shareholders. The Board term beginning on April 27, 2021 and ending on April 26, 2022 (the “2021 Board Term”) and the Board term beginning on April 28, 2020 and ending on April 27, 2021 (the “2020 Board Term”) do not coincide with MSCI’s January through|
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||53|
|December fiscal year. Amounts included in the table above represent cash earned or paid, or stock awards granted, as applicable, during the year ended December 31, 2021. Because directors are paid for service from May 1 to April 30, prorated amounts are calculated from the applicable date to May 1st of the relevant Board term.|
|(2)||Cash amounts in this column include the annual retainers and committee fees paid during the year ended December 31, 2021. Four of our directors elected to receive all or a portion of their annual cash retainers in stock as set forth below. The number of shares issued was determined by dividing the aggregate value of the elected portion of the cash retainer by the closing price of the Company’s common stock on the trading day prior to the grant date ($485.77 for Mr. Ashe and Mmes. Kinney and Volent and $461.97 for Mr. Taneja) and rounding down to the next whole share. Mr. Taneja elected to defer receipt of such shares until the earlier of June 1, 2025 and the 60th day after his “separation from service” as a director under the Deferral Plan.|
|Mr. Ashe||—||$||114,641.72 (236 shares)|
|Ms. Kinney||—||$||89,867.45 (185 shares)|
|Mr. Taneja||—||$||82,230.66 (178 shares)|
|Ms. Volent||—||$||99,582.85 (205 shares)|
|(3)||Represents the aggregate grant date fair value of RSUs granted in 2021 in accordance with FASB ASC Subtopic 718-10. The fair value is calculated by multiplying the closing price of our common stock on the date prior to the grant date by the number of units awarded. For assumptions regarding these calculations, please see notes 1 and 11 to the consolidated financial statements included in our 2021 Annual Report on Form 10-K filed with the SEC on February 11, 2022. However, the values in this column may not correspond to the actual value that will be realized by the non-employee directors at the time the RSUs vest. The number of RSUs awarded is determined by dividing the aggregate value of the RSU award by the closing price of the Company’s common stock on the trading day prior to the grant date ($485.77 for Messrs. Ashe, Edmunds, Perold, Rattray and Smith and Mmes. Kinney, Riefler and Volent and $468.13 for Mr. Taneja) and rounding down to the next whole RSU. For the 2021 Board term, each of Messrs. Edmunds, Perold, Rattray and Smith and Mmes. Kinney, Riefler and Volent received 339 RSUs, Mr. Taneja received 322 RSUs, and Mr. Ashe received 442 RSUs. These RSUs will vest on May 1, 2022. Ms. Riefler elected to defer receipt of such shares issuable upon vesting until the 60th day after her “separation from service” as a director under the Deferral Plan. Mr. Taneja elected to defer receipt of such shares until the earlier of June 1, 2025 and the 60th day after his “separation from service” as a director under the Deferral Plan.|
|(4)||As of December 31, 2021, each of our non-employee directors had the following outstanding stock awards in the form of RSUs: Messrs. Edmunds, Perold, Rattray and Smith and Mmes. Kinney, Riefler and Volent each had 339 RSUs outstanding, Mr. Taneja had 322 RSUs outstanding and Mr. Ashe had 442 RSUs outstanding.|
|(5)||Cash amounts in this column include dividend equivalents paid during the year ended December 31, 2021 in connection with the Company’s payment of its quarterly cash dividend. Each of Messrs. duPont and Taneja and Mmes. Kinney and Riefler received shares of our common stock and a cash payment for fractional shares received as a dividend equivalent payment for outstanding RSUs and in lieu of receiving a cash dividend payment for shares, in each case subject to his or her deferral election. The table below sets forth the amounts received by each.|
|Name||Shares|| Cash Received for|
|Mr. duPont||$||8,242.33 (19 shares)||$||916.43|
|Ms. Kinney||$||72,951.85 (137 shares)||$||1,153.87|
|(6)||Mr. duPont did not stand for re-election at the 2021 annual meeting of shareholders and served on the Board through April 27, 2021, and thus did not receive compensation for the 2021 Board Term.|
|(7)||Mr. Taneja was appointed to the Board, effective June 1, 2021.|
Non-Employee Director Stock Ownership Guidelines
Under the Company’s stock ownership guidelines for non-employee directors, commencing on April 28, 2016, each non-employee director has been required to own a target number of shares of stock of the Company equal to the sum of the “net shares” resulting from the vesting of the RSUs granted to such director for each of the last five years, with such aggregate share ownership to be achieved within five years of initially being elected or appointed to the Board and maintained thereafter. “Net Shares” means the number of shares that would remain if the shares underlying the equity awards are sold or withheld by the Company to (i) pay the
|54||MSCI | DIRECTOR COMPENSATION AND STOCK OWNERSHIP GUIDELINES|
exercise price of a stock option, (ii) satisfy any tax withholding obligations (assuming a tax rate of 50%) or (iii) satisfy any other applicable transaction costs.
Shares that count towards satisfaction of the target level of stock ownership under the stock ownership guidelines for non-employee directors consist of the following:
|(1)||Shares beneficially owned individually, either directly or indirectly (including any shares beneficially owned as a result of an election to receive a retainer (or any portion thereof) in shares);|
|(2)||Shares beneficially owned jointly with, or separately by, immediate family members residing in the same household, either directly or indirectly;|
|(3)||Shares underlying vested and unvested RSUs granted under the Directors Plan; and|
|(4)||Shares for which receipt has been deferred (including any shares held through the Deferral Plan or any other deferred compensation plan maintained by the Company).|
As of the date of this Proxy Statement, all of our non-employee directors are in compliance with the Company’s stock ownership guidelines.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||55|
Advisory Vote to Approve Executive Compensation (Say-on-Pay)
The Dodd-Frank Act enables MSCI’s shareholders to vote to approve, on an advisory or non-binding basis, the compensation of our NEOs as disclosed in this Proxy Statement in accordance with SEC rules.
For an overview of the compensation of our NEOs and our compensation strategy, see “Compensation Matters—Compensation Discussion and Analysis—Executive Summary” below.
We are asking for shareholder approval of the compensation of our NEOs as disclosed in this Proxy Statement in accordance with SEC rules, which include the disclosures under “Compensation Matters—Compensation Discussion and Analysis,” the compensation tables included herein and the narrative following the compensation tables. This vote is not intended to address any specific item of compensation, but rather the overall compensation of our NEOs and the policies and practices described in this Proxy Statement.
This vote is advisory and therefore not binding on MSCI, the Compensation Committee or the Board. The Board and the Compensation Committee value the opinions of MSCI’s shareholders. To the extent there is any significant vote against the NEO compensation as disclosed in this Proxy Statement, we will consider those shareholders’ concerns, and the Compensation Committee will evaluate whether any actions are necessary to address those concerns. MSCI currently conducts annual advisory votes on executive compensation.
VOTE REQUIRED AND RECOMMENDATION
The affirmative vote of a majority of the votes cast at our 2022 Annual Meeting, at which a quorum is present, is required to approve Proposal No. 2. Abstentions shall not be treated as votes cast.
Our Board of Directors Recommends a vote “FOR” the approval of the compensation of MSCI’s Named Executive Officers as disclosed in this proxy statement pursuant to the compensation disclosure rules of the SEC.
Proxies solicited by the Board will be voted “FOR” this approval unless otherwise instructed.
|57||Compensation Discussion and Analysis|
|58||Business Strategy and Compensation|
|58||2021 Business Highlights|
|60||Key 2021 Compensation Decisions|
|61||Key 2022 Compensation Decisions|
|63||Governance and Administration|
|63||Executive Compensation Philosophy and Goals|
|64||Executive Compensation Practices|
|65||Executive Compensation Process|
|66||Executive Compensation Considerations|
|69||Review of Our Programs|
|69||Elements of Executive Compensation|
|83||Stock Ownership Guidelines|
|85||Anti-Hedging and Anti-Pledging Policy|
|85||Compensation Risk Assessment|
|86||Compensation, Talent and Culture Committee Report|
|87||Executive Compensation Tables|
|87||Summary Compensation Table|
|88||Grants of Plan-Based Awards|
|89||Outstanding Equity Awards at Fiscal Year-End|
|91||Option Exercises and Stock Vested|
|91||Potential Payments Upon Termination or Change in Control|
|94||Termination or Change in Control|
|95||2021 Pay Ratio|
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||57|
This Compensation Discussion and Analysis (referred to as the “CD&A”) section summarizes our general philosophy with regard to the compensation of our Chief Executive Officer (“CEO”), our Chief Financial Officer (“CFO”) and Treasurer, and our three next most highly paid executive officers in 2021 (collectively referred to as “named executive officers” or “NEOs”). The CD&A provides context for the executive compensation disclosures presented below in both tabular and narrative form. Under its charter, the Compensation Committee reviews the Company’s compensation strategy and reviews and approves executive officer compensation as well as the Company’s compensation and benefits program generally. The Compensation Committee approved the compensation structure and amounts for each of our NEOs for 2021 and also approved enhancements to the long-term equity incentive component of our executive compensation program that became effective for equity grants in 2021 following feedback we received from our shareholders.
|C. D. BAER
|ROBERT J. |
|Chairman and Chief Executive Officer||Chief Financial Officer and Treasurer||President and Chief Operating Officer||Chief Human Resources Officer||General Counsel|
Our executive compensation program is designed to link pay to performance, encourage prudent decision-making and risk management, and create a balanced focus on short-term and long-term performance that fuels shareholder value creation. In the dynamic and competitive environment in which we operate, it is imperative that we maintain a responsible executive compensation program that encourages and rewards our leaders for achieving short-term and long-term results.
The following table sets forth the key components of our target-based compensation program in effect in 2021.
Each of the three components has a different purpose. The sum of the base salary, target annual cash incentive and target equity incentive creates a target total compensation. Actual cash incentive and equity incentive payouts are dependent upon the achievement of the relevant AIP and LTIP goals tied directly to the performance of the Company, the product/functional unit and the individual.
We believe that this target-based incentive structure fosters a culture of high performance and accountability and promotes shareholder interests by closely aligning executive compensation with objectively measured Company performance and strategic goal attainment as further described below.
|58||MSCI | COMPENSATION MATTERS|
The diagram below illustrates how our executive compensation program aligns the strategic initiatives underlying our corporate mission to generate long-term shareholder value creation. The metrics included in our compensation program are aligned with our strategic initiatives and are designed to measure the achievement of objectives that not only deliver short- and medium-term returns, but also help to build the foundation for long-term shareholder value creation.
to enable investors to build better
portfolios for a better world.
Strategic Pillars of Growth
|Extend leadership in research-
enhanced content across
|Lead the enablement of ESG and climate
|Enhance distribution and content-
|Expand solutions that empower
|Strengthen client relationships
and grow into strategic
partnerships with clients
|Execute strategic relationships and
acquisitions with complementary
content and technology companies
(ANNUAL INCENTIVE PLAN CASH BONUS)
● Restricted Stock Units (for 2021, ratable vest, and for 2022, cliff-vest after a three-year service period)
● Performance Stock Units (earned based on absolute TSR CAGR) with a 1-year post vesting mandatory holding period for 3-Year PSUs
● Performance Stock Options (earned based on cumulative revenue and cumulative Adjusted EPS) (new for 2022)
Execution on Strategic Priorities
Despite the economic uncertainties and social disruptions that continued throughout 2021, we delivered another year of strong results. In fact, MSCI set a new bar for performance across a number of key financial and operating metrics in 2021. Our intense client-centricity has enabled us to continue to serve as a go-to partner for our clients, and we believe that our performance in 2021 demonstrates the strength of our execution and the results of our key long-term investments. We achieved these results in 2021 while our employees continued to deliver exceptional performance in a largely remote-work environment.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||59|
Strong Financial Performance
|OPERATING REVENUES||DILUTED EPS / ADJUSTED EPS(1) |
|NET CASH PROVIDED BY OPERATING
ACTIVITY / FREE CASH FLOW(1)
|NET NEW SALES(2)|
|(in thousands)||(in thousands)|
|(1)||“Adjusted EPS” and “free cash flow” are non-GAAP financial measures. See Annex B for definitions and reconciliations of all non-GAAP financial measures referenced herein.|
|(2)||Net New Sales is defined as gross sales (new recurring subscription sales plus non-recurring sales) less subscription cancellations.|
For additional information about key strategic developments and milestones during 2021, please see the details under “KPI Component and DE&I Goals Component” on page 72 of this Proxy Statement.
|60||MSCI | COMPENSATION MATTERS|
In 2021, despite the continuing complex and challenging operating environment resulting from the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, our employees continued to display their resilience and dedication to our business, which was fundamental to the strong performance we achieved in 2021. The Company remained committed to nurturing and fostering an “owner-operator,” performance-based culture among employees that aligns compensation with the shareholder experience.
Specifically, in 2021, we granted a significant portion of our NEOs’ compensation in the form of “at-risk” variable compensation under the LTIP and the AIP. The 2021 LTIP awards granted to our NEOs consist of a mix of grants of annual RSUs and PSUs (including 3-Year PSUs and 5-Year PSUs) that varies based on the executive’s position, as further detailed on page 80 of this Proxy Statement. Consistent with our historical practice, Mr. Fernandez received 100% of his equity compensation in the form of PSUs, with 60% granted in the form of 5-Year PSUs and 40% granted in the form of 3-Year PSUs. In addition, for 2021, the Compensation Committee:
|●||Increased the proportion of Mr. Pettit’s 5-Year PSUs from 50% to 60% of his overall equity incentive compensation for 2021 (with the remaining 40% granted in the form of 3-Year PSUs), commensurate with Mr. Fernandez;|
|●||Added a one-year post-vest mandatory holding period to the 3-Year PSUs that were granted to our NEOs in 2021, where such shares, or rights with respect to such shares, may not be transferred until the expiration of such holding period; and|
|●||Under the AIP, introduced DE&I Goals for our senior leaders, linked to 10% of target annual cash bonus.|
The Compensation Committee believes that the complimentary performance metrics and associated performance cycles utilized under the AIP and LTIP collectively encourage our senior executives to manage our business with an “owner-operator” mindset that focuses on the long-term health of our business and the interests of our shareholders. Specifically, we believe that PSUs encourage a longer-term orientation to managing our business, while at the same time, the AIP serves as meaningful check and balance to ensure that our executive compensation program continues to measure and reward for performance against core financial, operational and strategic milestones in the near-term to fuel the long-term growth of shareholder value.
The key features of the 2021 RSUs and PSUs are as follows:
Granted to NEOs other than the CEO and President & COO
Service-vest in three equal installments in each of 2022, 2023 and 2024
Structure of this component was unchanged from prior years
Long-term value of underlying stock tied to share price
|3-YEAR TSR PSUs:|
|●||Granted to all NEOs to facilitate an “owner-operator” mindset|
|●||Cliff-vest at the end of a three-year performance cycle from February 3, 2021 to February 2, 2024, based on achievement of rigorous absolute TSR CAGR performance metrics|
|●||Reflect the right to receive between 0% and 300% of the target number of shares based on achievement of the TSR CAGR performance metric over the applicable performance period|
|●||Realize meaningful value only to the extent that shareholders also realize value|
|●||Include a one-year post-vest mandatory holding period, where such shares, or rights with respect to such shares, may not be transferred until the expiration of such holding period|
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||61|
5-YEAR TSR PSUs:
|●||Granted to all NEOs to facilitate an “owner-operator” mindset|
|●||Cliff-vest at the end of a five-year performance cycle from February 3, 2021 to February 2, 2026, based on achievement of rigorous absolute TSR CAGR performance metrics|
|●||Reflect the right to receive between 0% and 200% of the target number of shares based on achievement of the TSR CAGR performance metric over the applicable performance period|
|●||Provide “stretch” opportunity to reward for exceptional long-term value creation over a longer-than-typical performance period|
In 2021, with the help of its external independent compensation consultant, Semler Brossy, the Compensation Committee undertook a comprehensive process to research and evaluate an appropriate design for our 2022 LTIP that applies across MSCI, including to our NEOs, to ensure continued alignment of the LTIP with MSCI’s go-forward strategic objectives. As part of this review, the Compensation Committee evaluated our current LTIP design against the LTIP practices of our peers and broader industry LTIP practices. In particular, the Compensation Committee considered the following feedback from external and internal reviews, including the views of our shareholders:
|●||there was strong continued support for MSCI’s “owner-operator” culture that is advanced by the LTIP;|
|●||the LTIP should focus on a three-year performance period, which is more compelling because it is aligned with the timeframe of MSCI’s strategic planning; and|
|●||the Company should consider complementing the absolute TSR CAGR performance metric in the PSUs with financial metrics that are directly linked to the Company’s strategic plan. In particular, feedback to the Compensation Committee was that a focus on revenue and earnings provided the strongest links to MSCI’s go-forward strategy.|
After a thorough review and evaluation process, the Compensation Committee designed the 2022 LTIP to further enhance our pay-for-performance culture by incorporating the above described feedback and reviews and positioning the 2022 LTIP to support the Company’s strategic plan and the need to incentivize continued stock price appreciation. Specifically, the Compensation Committee made the following enhancements for 2022:
|●||introduced PSOs that are earned and vest based on achievement of two equally-weighted performance metrics that are directly linked to the Company’s strategic plan—cumulative revenue and cumulative adjusted EPS—each measured over a cumulative three-year performance period. The grant of the PSOs in 2022 replaced the 5-Year PSU component of our 2021 LTIP;|
|●||revised the vesting structure of annual RSU grants to cliff-vest 100% at the end of a three-year service period (rather than annual ratable vesting over a three-year period); and|
|●||updated the Company’s share ownership and retention guidelines to provide for even more rigorous requirements.|
As a result of these changes, and as discussed in more detail below, the Company’s 2022 LTIP consists of grants of annual RSUs, 3-year PSUs and PSOs, with the mix amongst the awards based on the executive’s level. The LTIP mix is tiered to align according to level, with our CEO and President & COO having the highest “at-risk” mix, by receiving 100% of their LTIP awards in the form of performance-based awards of PSUs and PSOs.
The 2022 PSOs were designed such that the Company’s senior leaders, including the NEOs, will only realize value from an award if our cumulative revenue and cumulative Adjusted EPS performance over the cumulative three-year period is above threshold and if increases in our stock price are sustained above the exercise price. As a result, the Compensation Committee believes that the PSOs will further align our executives’ interests with those of our shareholders by helping to drive performance and by complementing the TSR-based performance metrics applicable to the 3-Year PSUs, which will continue to reward participants for sustained exceptional growth in the Company’s stock price.
|62||MSCI | COMPENSATION MATTERS|
The key features of the 2022 RSUs, PSUs and PSOs are as follows:
|●||Granted to NEOs other than the CEO and President & COO|
|●||Cliff-vest at the end of a three-year vesting period (reflects a change from our historical practice of annual ratable vesting)|
|●||Long-term value of underlying stock tied to share price|
3-YEAR TSR PSUs:
|●||Granted to all NEOs|
|●||Cliff-vest at the end of a three-year performance period from February 3, 2022 to February 2, 2025, based on achievement of rigorous absolute TSR CAGR performance metrics|
|●||Reflect the right to receive between 0% and 300% of the target number of shares based on achievement of the TSR CAGR performance metric over the applicable performance period|
|●||Realize meaningful value only to the extent that shareholders also realize value|
|●||Include one-year post-vest mandatory holding period, where such shares, or rights with respect to such shares, may not be transferred until the expiration of such holding period|
|●||Granted to all NEOs to further facilitate an “owner-operator” mindset and focus on longer-term strategic goals|
|●||Vest upon satisfaction of both a service condition and a performance condition, with the service condition satisfied on the third anniversary of the grant date|
|●||Represent the right to exercise between 0% and 200% of the target number of shares subject to the option based on the combined level of achievement of a cumulative revenue performance goal and a cumulative adjusted EPS performance goal, each weighted at 50% and measured over a three-year performance period|
In addition, to further promote our “owner-operator” mindset, the Compensation Committee updated the Company’s Stock Ownership Guidelines for Executive Committee members, including our NEOs, to require that, in addition to existing requirements, our Executive Committee members must hold shares equivalent, in the aggregate, to 25% of the “Net Shares” from equity awards granted to them after January 1, 2022. The Compensation Committee also approved revisions to the minimum share ownership requirements to increase the thresholds applicable to members of our Executive Committee, including our NEOs, to be among the highest multiples of base salary in our peer group. See page 83 of this Proxy Statement for additional information with respect to our Executive Committee Stock Ownership Guidelines.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||63|
We evaluate our executive compensation structure on an annual basis to ensure alignment with our compensation philosophy and business strategy and shareholder priorities. Our compensation philosophy centers around maintaining a compensation program for our NEOs that is designed to promote the achievement of our short-term and long-term financial and strategic goals. For additional information on our strategic initiatives, see page 58 of this Proxy Statement.
In addition to the principles described in the “Executive Summary” on page 57 of this Proxy Statement, our executive compensation program is designed to:
|●||promote achievement of the Company’s financial and strategic goals and provide alignment with the objectives of our multi-year strategic plan;|
|●||provide a framework to advance our strategic goals and encourage our NEOs to make a long-term commitment to the Company;|
|●||base compensation determinations on the performance of the Company, the product/functional unit and the individual;|
|●||attract, retain and engage top-level talent and provide each NEO with compensation opportunities that are competitive with market practices and within our cost structure;|
|●||appropriately manage compensation risk in light of our business strategy; and|
|●||align the long-term interests of our senior executives with those of our shareholders by promoting actions that will allow for sustainable top- and bottom-line growth opportunities and capital returns to shareholders and maintain an “owner-operator” culture and strong corporate governance practices.|
Our executive compensation philosophy provides our NEOs with the opportunity to earn a significant portion of their compensation in the form of variable compensation (i.e., annual cash incentive awards under our AIP and long-term equity incentive awards under our LTIP), with the remaining portion of their total compensation as their base salary. This emphasis on variable compensation is illustrated in the following pay mix charts:
|2021 ANNUALIZED CEO||2021 AVERAGE ANNUALIZED OTHER NEOS|
|64||MSCI | COMPENSATION MATTERS|
Our executive compensation practices incorporate the following corporate governance best practices that protect the interests of our shareholders and are consistent with high standards of risk management.
|WHAT WE DO||WHAT WE DON’T DO|
● Emphasize variable compensation
● Provide formula-based annual cash incentive opportunities
● Subject equity awards to rigorous service- and performance-vesting requirements
● Impose rigorous stock ownership guidelines and requirements on all of our NEOs and other Executive Committee members, with guidelines among the highest multiples of base salary in our peer group
● 12x annual base salary for our CEO and President & COO
● 8x annual base salary for our other NEOs
● 4x annual base salary for other Executive Committee members
● In addition to the above, beginning with awards granted in 2022, require members of our Executive Committee, including our NEOs, to hold shares equivalent, in the aggregate, to 25% of the net shares they receive (after payment of taxes, exercise price and related costs) from equity awards until they no longer serve on the Executive Committee, reflecting MSCI’s deep commitment to an “owner-operator” mindset
● Maintain a clawback policy for incentive based-compensation (cash and equity) with provisions that cover a broad range of detrimental conduct and financial restatements
● Provide for double-trigger vesting upon a change in control
● Only pay dividend equivalents on PSUs if and when the underlying award vests
● Make CEO’s and President & COO’s equity grant entirely in awards tied to performance metrics, to focus on long-term shareholder value creation
● Retain an independent compensation consultant at the direction of the Compensation Committee
● Incorporate DE&I and climate-related considerations into our AIP program
● Do not provide gross-ups to cover excise taxes
● Do not allow any directors or employees, including all NEOs, to hedge or pledge the Company’s common stock, engage in short sales, purchases or sales of options, puts or calls, as well as derivatives such as swaps, forwards or futures or trade on a short-term basis in the Company’s common stock
● Do not allow repricing of options or stock appreciation rights awards without shareholder approval
● Do not provide for “liberal” share recycling when shares are tendered or withheld to satisfy tax withholding obligations or as payment of an option exercise price
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||65|
The executive compensation program described in this section is the result of a year-long process:
● Review and determine the AIP awards for prior-year performance for NEOs based on an assessment of the Company’s achievement of the financial metrics established for the prior year, as well as the executive’s achievement of his or her individual KPIs and DE&I Goals for such prior year. The CEO makes recommendations to the Compensation Committee on compensation for NEOs (other than himself), and the Compensation Committee takes these recommendations into consideration in reaching its final compensation decisions.
● Certify achievement of TSR metrics and any other performance metrics applicable to any equity awards granted in prior years.
● Establish the AIP structure for the current year, including the applicable AIP financial metrics and target AIP awards for each NEO.
● Establish the structure and performance metrics applicable to equity awards to be granted under the LTIP for the current year, and grant equity awards based on a number of factors, including the Company’s recent performance, peer analysis and the executive’s individual performance and potential future contributions.
|MARCH||● Consider risks arising from the Company’s incentive compensation plans.|
● Review Say-on-Pay voting recommendations from proxy advisors and our shareholder vote at our annual meeting.
● Review and approve KPIs for current year’s AIP.
|JULY TO OCTOBER||
● Review our status and progress on our performance culture.
● Review senior management fit for role and potential successors.
● Review peer group.
● Independent compensation consultant reports on compensation practices and trends in the industry.
● Review design of next year’s executive compensation programs.
● NEOs summarize preliminary results against their current-year KPIs and prepare preliminary KPIs for the upcoming year.
● Meet with shareholders to discuss our executive compensation policies and collect feedback.
|DECEMBER||● Finalize design of executive compensation program for upcoming year and review preliminary recommendations for actual and target levels of compensation.|
● Management provides feedback from shareholder outreach regarding our executive compensation program.
● Review progress made on performance metrics.
● Monitor compliance with stock ownership guidelines.
|66||MSCI | COMPENSATION MATTERS|
Independent Compensation Consultant
The Compensation Committee selected and engaged Semler Brossy as its independent compensation consultant to assist with a range of executive compensation matters, including the overall design of our executive compensation program, evaluation and selection of peer group companies, provision of competitive market data and other matters related to our NEO compensation program. During 2021, Semler Brossy was present at all Compensation Committee meetings and consulted on executive compensation matters. The Compensation Committee recognizes that it is important to receive objective advice from its outside advisor and regularly meets with Semler Brossy in Executive Session without management’s attendance. Semler Brossy reports directly to the Compensation Committee, which, pursuant to its charter, maintains sole responsibility for retaining or terminating the compensation consultant. Semler Brossy did not provide any other services to MSCI during 2021.
The Compensation Committee takes into account a range of factors in determining compensation components and setting compensation amounts. In addition to reviewing NEO performance against annual goals, various financial and operational metrics, KPIs and DE&I Goals, the Compensation Committee reviews peer group analyses provided by Semler Brossy (used as a reference without benchmarking to a specified target) and shareholder feedback. The weight attributed to each individual factor may change from time to time, depending on the circumstances of such decisions. We believe this continues to be the best approach for the Company, as it enables the Compensation Committee to balance competing interests, address evolving priorities and meet Company objectives.
2021 Say-on-Pay Vote Results
In 2021, 96.8% of the votes cast on the Say-on-Pay Advisory Vote were voted in support of the compensation of our NEOs.
HIGH APPROVAL FOR THE LAST 4 YEARS
MSCI has established a robust process for engaging shareholders on executive compensation. On at least an annual basis, we meet with shareholders to provide an overview of our executive compensation program and highlight changes, if any, that have been made since our last meeting with the relevant shareholder. In 2021, the Company met with 14 of its largest shareholders (representing approximately 41% of its outstanding shares as of September 30, 2021) in individual meetings to discuss our corporate responsibility practices, including our executive compensation program. None of the shareholders expressed significant concerns with the Company’s compensation program, and the shareholders generally reacted positively to the Company’s compensation program.
Our 2021 and 2022 compensation programs reflect feedback we received from our shareholders.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||67|
|RECENT ENHANCEMENTS IN RESPONSE TO SHAREHOLDER FEEDBACK|
|WHAT WE HEARD||WHAT WE DID||WHY|
|Support for cultivating an “owner-operator” mindset||Added a one-year post-vest mandatory holding period to our 3-Year PSUs granted in 2021||We believe that equity award features that promote an “owner-operator” culture focus our senior leaders on long-term shareholder value creation|
|Stronger linkages between ESG and our compensation program||In 2021, introduced DE&I Goals for our senior leaders||We believe that integrating DE&I Goals into our compensation programs ensures executive decision making that aligns with our corporate culture|
|Request for disclosure around how the COVID-19 pandemic impacted our compensation program||In 2021, added disclosures to reflect the Compensation Committee’s decision not to make any changes to the performance goals under the AIP or LTIP (including the target performance levels or actual achievement levels) for 2021 in response to the pandemic, including for any currently outstanding awards||While the Company was less severely impacted by the pandemic than those in other industries, we believe that our compensation program is designed to reflect the economic realities of the operating environment and align with the impact of the operating environment on our stakeholders|
|Stronger facilitation of an “owner-operator” mindset and focus on longer-term strategic goals||
In 2022, granted PSOs with a three-year performance period, based on the combined level of achievement of operating and financial metrics, and a ten-year term. PSOs replaced the grant of 5-Year PSUs
Implemented more rigorous stock ownership and retention guidelines
We believe that the grant of PSOs with a focus on financial and operating metrics will complement the metrics used in PSUs and provide greater incentives for the execution of the Company’s strategic plan
We believe our 2022 LTIP program together with our enhanced stock ownership guidelines will further an “owner-operator” mindset
|Request for disclosure around how our Compensation Committee assessed performance for purposes of DE&I Goals||In 2022, added disclosure regarding NEO performance with respect to DE&I Goals as well as the Company-wide approach to assessing performance against DE&I Goals through our Executive Accountability Framework||We believe it is important to convey transparent information around the achievement of DE&I Goals by our senior leaders as well as our process of assessing those goals|
The Company will continue to maintain an active dialogue with shareholders and evaluate feedback on issues of importance to them, including the metrics that drive each of our NEO’s compensation. See page 40 of this Proxy Statement for additional information on our shareholder engagement efforts in 2021.
To ensure competitiveness of compensation structures and pay levels for our NEOs, the Compensation Committee conducts an annual review of peer company compensation data. Each year, prior to beginning this review, the Compensation Committee examines the composition of companies previously considered our peer companies to make certain that the selected companies continue to be relevant as evaluated according to the following screening criteria:
|●||Scale, to reflect similar size and complexity;|
|●||Geographic footprint, to reflect business structure and international complexity;|
|●||Public ownership structure to ensure availability of data;|
|●||Competitors for talent; and|
|●||Similar business model.|
|68||MSCI | COMPENSATION MATTERS|
The peer group used to inform fiscal 2021 pay decisions for our NEOs was comprised of 16 companies that, in aggregate, approximated MSCI’s size, scope of operations, and operating metrics. In particular, the group was selected such that it, in aggregate:
|●||Approximated MSCI’s size on a revenue basis for fiscal 2021;|
|●||Reflected MSCI’s high-margin, high-valuation operating metrics and international reach; and/or|
|●||Represented the competitive talent market for financial technology, research and consulting, and data systems/information technology companies.|
|MSCI Inc.||Financials—Capital Markets—Financial Exchanges and Data|
|Aspen Technology Inc.||Information Technology—IT Services—Application Software|
|Black Knight Inc.||Information Technology—IT Services—Data Processing and Outsourced Services|
|Dun & Bradstreet||Industrials—Professional Services—Research and Consulting Services|
|Equifax Inc.||Industrials—Professional Services— Research and Consulting Services|
|FactSet Research Systems Inc.||Financials—Capital Markets—Financial Exchanges and Data|
|Fair Isaac Corporation||Information Technology—Software—Application Software|
|Gartner, Inc.||Information Technology—IT Services—IT Consulting and Other Services|
|IHS Markit Ltd.||Industrials—Professional Services—Research and Consulting Services|
|MarketAxess Holdings Inc.||Financials—Capital Markets—Financial Exchanges and Data|
|Moody’s Corporation||Financials—Capital Markets—Financial Exchanges and Data|
|Morningstar, Inc.||Financials—Capital Markets—Financial Exchanges and Data|
|SEI Investments Company||Financials—Capital Markets—Asset Management and Custody Banks|
|S&P Global Inc.||Financials—Capital Markets—Financial Exchanges and Data|
|SS&C Technologies Holdings, Inc.||Information Technology—Software—Application Software|
|TransUnion||Industrials—Professional Services—Research and Consulting Services|
|Verisk Analytics, Inc.||Industrials—Professional Services—Research and Consulting Services|
Review for 2022
In its annual review of the executive compensation peer group for 2022, the Compensation Committee undertook a holistic review of the executive compensation peer group and determined the group to be sufficiently robust for market comparisons and balances. Accordingly, the Compensation Committee maintained the same peer group, as the selected companies met the same criteria described above for 2021 and the group continued to be an appropriate size.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||69|
Our executive compensation program in 2021 generally consisted of the following elements. We have also noted changes implemented in 2022 where applicable.
ANNUAL BASE SALARY
|Provides certainty and predictability to meet ongoing living and other financial commitments||● The only fixed component of our executive compensation program|
● The only fixed component of our executive compensation program.
● In 2022, each of Messrs. Wiechmann and Gutowski received an increase to his annual base salary after a consideration of several factors, including peer group market data and competitive practices
|Intended to drive one-year performance results against financial targets and other Company, individual and leadership focused goals||
● Metrics vary by executive, but include:
● Adjusted EPS
● Net New Sales
● Free Cash Flow
● Key Performance Indicator/Leadership Effectiveness Goals
● DE&I Goals
|No change to metrics|
|Fosters an “owner-operator” mindset, closely aligns management’s interests with the long-term interests of our shareholders and promotes the retention of key members of our management team||
● RSUs which ratably service vest over three years
● Grant of 3-Year PSUs and 5-Year PSUs (which vest based on absolute TSR)
● 3-Year PSUs cover a cumulative three-year performance period
● 5-Year PSUs cover a cumulative five-year performance period
● Each of Messrs. Fernandez and Pettit received 100% of their LTIP awards in the form of PSUs for 2021, with 60% of their PSUs granted in the form of 5-Year PSUs, the highest percentage amongst all of our NEOs for 2021 (for Mr. Pettit, an increase from 50% in 2020)
● RSUs which cliff vest after a three-year vesting period
● Grant of 3-Year PSUs (which vest based on absolute TSR)
● PSOs with a three-year performance period which vest based on the combined level of achievement of a cumulative adjusted EPS performance metric and a cumulative revenue performance metric
● Each of Messrs. Fernandez and Pettit received 100% of their LTIP awards in the form of performance awards, with 50% in the form of PSUs and 50% in the form of PSOs, with other NEOs receiving a mix of 30% RSUs, 35% PSOs and 35% PSUs
|70||MSCI | COMPENSATION MATTERS|
Annual Base Salary
Base salary is the only fixed component of our executive compensation program. The annual base salary element offers our NEOs a measure of certainty and predictability to meet ongoing living and other financial commitments. In setting base salaries for our NEOs, the Compensation Committee has sought to establish base salary rates that (i) are competitive with those provided for similar positions at companies in our peer group and (ii) recognize the experience and performance of the NEO. The Compensation Committee reviews the base salaries of our NEOs on an annual basis. None of our NEOs received an increase in base salary for 2021.
|Name||2021 Base Salary Rate ($)|
|Henry A. Fernandez||1,000,000|
|Andrew C. Wiechmann||500,000|
|C. D. Baer Pettit(1)||859,819|
|Scott A. Crum||550,000|
|Robert J. Gutowski||450,000|
|(1)||Base salary for Mr. Pettit was paid in British pounds sterling and converted to U.S. dollars using the fiscal year average of daily spot rates of £1 to $1.37571. Mr. Pettit’s 2021 base salary rate was £625,000.|
The variable compensation actually paid to our NEOs is subject to performance metrics that are designed to (i) emphasize pay for performance, (ii) balance short-term and long-term incentives, and (iii) take into account input from our shareholders. The variable elements of our target-based incentive compensation program include:
(1) an annual cash incentive component; and
(2) a long-term equity incentive component.
In determining target cash and equity incentive compensation amounts for each NEO, the Compensation Committee takes into account a number of factors, including: the differences in relative responsibilities; experience and performance in role; the ability to impact overall Company performance; Company, product segment and individual performance; and historical compensation and peer group analyses (used as a reference without benchmarking to a specified target).
There is no minimum amount of variable compensation payable to the NEOs. The Compensation Committee makes determinations, in its discretion, as to the amounts of variable compensation awarded based on program metrics and individual performance, subject to the terms of any applicable plan or arrangement.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||71|
Annual Cash Incentives
The Company awards annual cash incentives pursuant to the Company’s AIP, which closely aligns management’s interests with those of shareholders by employing a formulaic approach that takes into account specific financial criteria and individual KPIs and DE&I Goals when determining cash incentives. The Compensation Committee believes that subjecting 70% of the target cash incentive to pre-established performance targets further promotes shareholder value creation by more directly aligning executive compensation with Company performance and strategic goal attainment. Under the AIP, each NEO is eligible to earn an annual target cash incentive and may receive between 0% and 150% of their target cash incentive opportunity based on attainment of the level of certain financial performance metrics (together, weighted at 70%), individual KPIs (weighted at 20%) and DE&I Goals (weighted at 10%). For 2021, the target cash incentive opportunity, metrics, and corresponding weightings for our NEOs are included in the table set forth below:
|Financial Component—Overall Weighting of 70%|
|Name||2021 Target Cash
|Henry A. Fernandez||$||1,400,000||20.0%||30.0%||40.0%||10.0%||20.0%||10.0%|
|Andrew C. Wiechmann||$||600,000||20.0%||30.0%||40.0%||10.0%||20.0%||10.0%|
|C. D. Baer Pettit(1)||$||1,238,139||20.0%||30.0%||40.0%||10.0%||20.0%||10.0%|
|Scott A. Crum||$||700,000||20.0%||30.0%||40.0%||10.0%||20.0%||10.0%|
|Robert J. Gutowski||$||650,000||20.0%||30.0%||40.0%||10.0%||20.0%||10.0%|
|(1)||The 2021 target annual cash incentive opportunity reflected in the table above for Mr. Pettit was converted from British pounds sterling to U.S. dollars using the fiscal year average of daily spot rates of £1 to $1.37571 for fiscal 2021. Mr. Pettit’s actual 2021 target cash incentive amount was £900,000.|
The threshold, target and maximum for each financial component making up the AIP, as well as the actual results attained for 2021, are included in the table set forth below.
|Payout (% Of
|Payout (% Of
|Payout (% Of
|Payout (% Of|
Earnings Per Share
|MSCI Total Net||225.3||70%||50%||100%||100%||130%||150%||112.3%||120.4%|
|Free Cash Flow||687.1||85%||50%||100%||100%||115%||150%||128.5%||150%|
|(1)||Except Adjusted EPS, which is not stated in millions.|
|(2)||In determining the actual results attained for the Total Net New Sales metric under the 2021 AIP, the Compensation Committee made an adjustment to the Company’s reported results in accordance with the terms of the AIP, which permits the Compensation Committee to make adjustments, in whole or in part, to any performance measures (and the methodologies relating to such measures) for certain events specified in the AIP. Specifically, the Compensation Committee made an adjustment to the reported results for the Total Net New Sales metric to recognize a one-time customer payment in 2021 of $18 million. The Compensation Committee made this adjustment because the customer payment resulted in economic benefits to the Company similar to a non-recurring sale, but, absent this adjustment, would not have been taken into account under the Total Net New Sales category in 2021 or future years given the nature of the performance metrics. Non-recurring sales are credited at 75% for the Total Net New Sales category for compensation purposes under the AIP. As a result, there was a positive adjustment to the achievement of the Total Net New Sales metric under the 2021 AIP of $13.5 million.|
|72||MSCI | COMPENSATION MATTERS|
In determining the actual cash incentive amounts awarded under the 2021 AIP, the Compensation Committee made certain adjustments to the target financial metrics applicable to our NEOs in accordance with the terms of the AIP, which permits the Compensation Committee to make adjustments, in whole or in part, to any performance measures (including target performance levels) for certain events specified in the AIP. Specifically, the Compensation Committee made adjustments to the target metrics listed below to take into account the impact resulting from (1) the Company’s acquisition of RCA on September 13, 2021 and (2) accelerated cash tax payments that impacted the Company’s free cash flow in 2021 and that were not originally part of the Company’s operating plan.
|MSCI Total Net New Sales||222.2||+3.1||225.3|
|Free Cash Flow||790.1||-103.0||687.1|
KPI COMPONENT AND DE&I GOALS COMPONENT
The Compensation Committee believes that including KPIs (20% of the target AIP cash bonus amount) and DE&I Goals (10% of the target AIP cash bonus amount) under the AIP provides an opportunity to assess individual results against specific goals as well as progress against multi-year efforts. The Compensation Committee regularly assesses the components and metrics used in the AIP and the weighting of those components and metrics, in addition to taking into account shareholder feedback.
In 2021, we accelerated our commitment to advancing DE&I by linking the AIP target compensation of each Managing Director, including each of our NEOs, to DE&I progress. Our Managing Directors’ DE&I Goals are intended to ensure long-term stability at the Company, align with our long-term strategy and enhance our DE&I objectives. In particular, our CEO’s KPIs and DE&I Goals are directly tied to long-term strategic transformation, succession planning, new-hire onboarding and strengthening MSCI’s culture of inclusion and belonging, all of which build a strong foundation for future growth.
We developed an Executive Accountability Framework (“EAF”) to establish the philosophy and process to assess each Managing Director’s progress against DE&I Goals and overall DE&I performance, considering specific goals set by each Managing Director at the beginning of the year. The EAF stresses that creating an inclusive environment is as important as improving diverse representation; therefore, Managing Directors are assessed on their qualitative and quantitative results with a range of potential outcomes including those relating to talent development, retention, hiring practices and engagement. In addition, leaders are assessed as to whether they consistently display inclusive leadership behaviors and drive activity that fosters an inclusive environment. Each NEO was assessed individually with further calibration across all NEOs. Performance recommendations were then made to the Compensation Committee, which reviewed and approved performance in respect of each NEO.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||73|
|HENRY A. FERNANDEZ, CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER|
|Drive exceptional financial performance and enhance capital management|
● Achieved exceptional results in 2021, demonstrating the strength of an ambitious strategy, key long-term investments and consistent execution, along with unprecedented demand for the Company’s solutions.
● Highlights include the following (versus 2020):
● 2021 Full-Year Operating Revenue of $2.04 billion, up 20.5%.
● 2021 Full-Year Net New Sales up 48.7%.
● 2021 Full-Year Adjusted EPS* up 27.1%.
● 2021 Full-Year Free Cash Flow* up 16.2%.
● Expanded MSCI’s role as a change agent for the global investment industry.
● Led strategic progress in providing the common language and tools investors use for indexation, risk management, factors, ESG, climate and other key investment categories.
● Oversaw “triple crown” investments to help fuel future growth and meet client demand, including through the acquisition of Real Capital Analytics, a global commercial real estate data provider.
● Returned capital to shareholders, including opportunistically repurchasing approximately $140 million of MSCI common stock and returning approximately $300 million to shareholders in the form of quarterly dividends (increase of approximately 23% versus 2020).
|Drive shareholder value through strategic partnerships and product launches|
● Prioritized the development and introduction of new products and services to accelerate growth, and launched new partnerships to capture emerging opportunities. Examples include:
● Launched new ISaaS products, including Data Explorer, Climate Lab Enterprise and Index Builder.
● Entered into new partnership agreement with Royalty Pharma plc to expand MSCI’s existing thematic index suite with new indexes that aim to represent the performance of long-term, cutting-edge companies that are expected to disrupt the biopharmaceuticals and life sciences industries.
● Licensed China A 50 Connect Index to HKEX, leading to the most successful launch ever of an MSCI index-linked futures contract.
● Jointly created the MSCI COLCAP Index with the Colombia Stock Exchange.
● Advanced the Company’s long-term strategy through a partnership agreement with Goldman Sachs Global Markets to distribute portfolio-level Barra factor analytics to clients via its Marquee platform, its digital storefront for Goldman Sachs, and select third-party content.
|Advance MSCI’s climate capabilities and helped clients transition to a Net-Zero world|
● Continued to steer MSCI’s leadership in providing the transparency clients need to better integrate ESG and climate risks and opportunities into investment processes. Launched several significant ESG and Climate tools and solutions, including:
● Net-Zero Tracker, a quarterly gauge of progress by public companies toward curbing climate risk. The Tracker calculates the individual and aggregate emissions of all MSCI ACWI-IMI companies and highlights leading and lagging companies and sectors in the path towards net-zero emissions.
● Climate Lab Enterprise, which helps investors monitor and manage climate-related risks.
● Implied Temperature Rise, a search tool that computes and discloses how the emissions trajectories of companies, portfolios and funds align with different global temperature pathways.
● Carbon Footprinting of Private Equity and Debt Funds, a product jointly developed with Burgiss and MSCI’s ESG team, which measures the carbon emissions of 15,000 private companies and the carbon intensity of nearly 4,000 private equity and debt funds.
● Prioritized MSCI’s own climate goals through a more robust commitment to corporate responsibility, including by the introduction of MSCI’s goal of net-zero carbon emissions by 2040 throughout its global operations and by becoming a founding member of the Net Zero Financial Service Providers Alliance.
|*||“Adjusted EPS” and “free cash flow” are non-GAAP financial measures. See Annex B for definitions and reconciliations of all non-GAAP financial measures referenced herein.|
|74||MSCI | COMPENSATION MATTERS|
|Strengthen MSCI’s commitment to building a diverse, equitable and inclusive culture|
● Championed and intensified the focus across MSCI on DE&I outcomes. Amplified engagement and accountability:
● Appointed first Chief Diversity Officer.
● Introduced DE&I Executive Accountability Framework, aligned with the firm’s compensation process and the introduction of individual DE&I Goals for senior leaders tied to incentive compensation.
● Enhanced commitment and approach to identifying and attracting senior diverse talent, which resulted in hiring 11 Managing Directors across functions and geographies, many from diverse or under-represented backgrounds, including four female and three Black executives.
● Strengthened MSCI’s culture of inclusion and belonging:
● Conducted listening tour with 16 local offices, where DE&I was a key topic of discussion.
● Hosted a global conversation with the MSCI Pride ERG leaders to gather feedback on important issues affecting the LGBTQ+ community.
● Conducted a fireside chat at the 4th Annual Global DE&I Summit in November, celebrating and recognizing the achievements of the Executive Diversity Council and employee resource group leaders.
● Focused on employee engagement and empowerment:
● Drove MSCI’s Future of Work transformation through the development of a forward-looking, hybrid-work strategy centered on client-centricity, trust and empowerment.
● According to our December 2021 employee engagement survey (not including employees from newly acquired companies), the percentage of respondents characterized as fully engaged equaled the highest since we implemented the survey.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||75|
|ANDREW C. WIECHMANN, CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER AND TREASURER|
|Drive financial management excellence|
● Established “Finance at the Front” initiative to drive deeper insights, enhanced decision making, proactive focus on business improvement and achievement of financial targets.
● Drove enhancements to overall financial management process, including the internal capital allocation process to ensure a rigorous and intense focus on triple-crown investment activity and firm-wide efficiencies.
● Proactively managed investments and firm resources to capitalize on market opportunities, drive financial performance and ensure strong execution, with a focus on value creation, helping to drive record financial results for 2021 across key metrics.
|Champion continued transformation of the finance organization and firmwide processes|
● Continued intense focus on process simplification and automation to improve efficiency.
● Rationalized, simplified and automated internal reporting.
● Oversaw successful deployment of enhanced revenue management system and broader subscription revenue processes.
● Drove alignment and enhanced decision making through key metric visibility, improved forecasting and process discipline.
● Incorporated risk management in operating rhythm to ensure broader awareness around and intentionality in levels of Company risk.
● Continued buildout of business intelligence capabilities to enhance understanding of markets and competitors, improve decision making and optimize outcomes.
|Enhance capital discipline and further optimize capital structure|
● Advanced firmwide focus on optimizing cash flow dynamics of the business through proactive working capital management and enhanced client contract discipline.
● Capitalized on attractive market opportunities to enhance credit profile, lower cost of capital and extend maturities.
● Executed $1.8 billion of new financing transactions, including refinancing $1 billion of outstanding debt, and extended the life of our revolving credit facility.
● Meaningfully extended debt maturities (with the earliest maturity being eight years out) and materially reduced weighted average cost of debt.
● Achieved an investment grade rating from Fitch and an upgrade from Moody’s.
|Further instill firmwide culture of mergers, partnerships and acquisitions (“MP&A”)|
● Drove enhanced firmwide focus on MP&A to accelerate key strategic growth areas and enable further business expansion.
● Formalized processes with product and functional leaders to develop and manage MP&A opportunity pipeline in order to drive focus and accountability.
● Successfully attracted and onboarded key new Strategy and Corporate Development hire to help drive MP&A culture.
● Successfully executed and drove value realization of two acquisitions, two minority investments and 20+ strategic partnerships in priority areas.
● Implemented new policies and procedures for engaging with existing and prospective partners to ensure alignment with MSCIs corporate responsibility objectives.
|Enhance diverse representation within the finance organization and throughout MSCI|
● As a result of expanded recruiting outreach to broader qualified talent pool, increased diversity in Finance organization globally.
● Championed diversity in all talent development, promotion and succession decisions in the Finance organization to ensure all talent is being appropriately considered and supported.
● Acted as Executive Sponsor of All Abilities Network.
● Active participant as speaker/sponsor of ERGs: Women’s Leadership Forum, MSCI Pride, Black Leadership Network and All Abilities Network; participant in 4th Annual Global DE&I Summit.
|76||MSCI | COMPENSATION MATTERS|
|BAER PETTIT, PRESIDENT & CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER|
|Prioritize investment targets to drive growth|
● Drove greater investment into high growth areas and delivered strong financial and operating results:
● Drove record financial results and growth in 2021 across key metrics.
● Oversaw the execution of record sales and performance against key operating metrics in 2021.
● Oversaw an increase in MSCI’s footprint in private assets through the acquisition of Real Capital Analytics.
● Drove the 2022 Operating Plan process by emphasizing critical growth areas, with a heightened focus on client-centricity. Continued to identify and prioritize efficiencies to create additional investment capacity.
|Accelerate technology transformation|
● Transformed technology function by strengthening technology leadership team through key hires in ESG and Climate and Index, and by targeting greater investment into critical technology initiatives:
● Directed investment into new ISaaS offerings.
● Oversaw the development and release of new thematic indexes via Barra Portfolio Manager.
● Drove progress on cloud migration across multiple product lines in a cost-efficient manner, including the complete migration of ESG and Climate applications and services.
|Focus on being partner of choice and helping our clients build better portfolios|
● Oversaw improvements to client experience by simplifying contract structures, promoting greater automation and adding tools to help clients find relevant content more efficiently.
● Optimized incentive compensation programs within the Client Coverage organization to drive focus on client-centricity.
● Prioritized the “Wealth” client segment, leveraging our various tools and solutions to better capitalize on the growing demand for customization in investment processes.
● Prioritized focus on new research, including related to ESG and Climate and Thematics, to provide clarity on key investment problems.
● Developed new ESG and Climate solutions, including through the launch of the first Paris Aligned Fixed Income indexes in the market.
|Instill practices that support an inclusive and innovative culture|
● Actively supported efforts to ensure that all Managing Directors have, and are measured against, specific and individualized DE&I Goals.
● Served as executive sponsor for the Pride and Allies ERGs, including by hosting a town hall and speaking at the Pride and Allies Summit.
● Conducted career conversations to support internal succession planning for key roles within the Research and Product functions.
● Supported development of a leadership profile to evaluate candidates more objectively for assessment, selection and promotion.
● Oversaw use of MSCI’s innovation ‘Breakthrough’ methodology in numerous areas, including talent attraction and mobility, Future of Work challenges and DE&I initiatives, resulting in the establishment of transformational practices around recruiting and hybrid-work collaboration.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||77|
|SCOTT A. CRUM, CHIEF HUMAN RESOURCES OFFICER|
|Strengthen our senior talent pipeline|
● Significantly accelerated Executive Committee succession and progression planning by focusing on preparing internal senior talent and identifying external pipeline of senior talent.
● Created Managing Director and Executive Committee success profiles, which will serve as the basis for future selection, promotion and progression decisions.
● Developed Managing Director assessment, selection, promotion and progression methodology.
● Hired 11 Managing Directors in 2021, with strong diversity across both gender and ethnicity.
● Developed rigorous approach for identifying specific capability gaps for converting learning programs, including our flagship leadership and management programs, to virtual.
● Expanded learning offerings, including programs to support our Future of Work implementation, inclusive leadership efforts and the well-being of our people.
|Advance our culture of diversity, equity and inclusion|
● Appointed MSCI’s first Chief Diversity Officer, responsible for operating across MSCI to align our DE&I goals with business outcomes.
● Introduced DE&I metrics for Managing Directors tied to 10% of target annual cash incentive compensation.
● Hired thirty-six interns to the One MSCI internship program in New York, Chicago and London.
● Launched three new ERGs in 2021: Asian Support Network, All Abilities Network and Hola! MSCI.
● Offered unconscious bias training to all employees globally, using a science-based approach with practical applications, to raise awareness of bias and create a more inclusive culture.
● Enhanced pay equity practices for all female new hires.
|Continue to support and enhance our performance and growth culture|
● Developed and implemented our comprehensive Future of Work program that contained vision, principles and global guidelines.
● Led organizational design initiative, which yielded new organizational design and senior leadership structure.
● Redesigned our long-term incentive program to further support an “owner-operator” culture.
● Positioned MSCI as a place for climate-focused talent to build their careers.
● Using MSCI’s “Breakthrough Methodology,” transformed the way MSCI attracts and recruits.
● Sponsored initiatives focused on increasing speed and quality of hiring.
● Established Human Resources Operational Effectiveness Team to allow various teams within the Human Resources organization to work under a singular vision of driving the creation and adoption of innovative data, technology and operational solutions.
|78||MSCI | COMPENSATION MATTERS|
|ROBERT J. GUTOWSKI, GENERAL COUNSEL|
|Enhance corporate governance and responsibility practices and profile, including advancing ESG and climate initiatives|
● Advised on and championed increased ESG reporting and related shareholder engagement.
● Counseled Chief Responsibility Officer and CRC on climate initiatives, including net-zero commitments and related company policies, activities and initiatives.
● Managed compliance with global legal requirements related to pandemic response, including advising on return-to-work protocols and implementation of MSCI’s Future of Work program across more than 20 countries.
|Lead development of client contracting efficiencies to improve client experience and accelerate/grow sales|
● Improved client contract automation processes.
● Increased deal speed and capacity.
● Simplified contract structures and ease of licensing across multiple product lines under a single client contract.
● Facilitated enterprise scale transactions and relationships.
● Enhanced cross-functional coordination of contract lifecycle from contract inception through signature and booking.
|Expand engagement with regulators and policymakers|
● Successfully onboarded a Head of Government and Regulatory Affairs to coordinate proactive engagement globally.
● Established productive relationships and open dialogues with key regulators in multiple jurisdictions, with a focus on enhancing their understanding of the scope, role and uses of our ESG and climate and index products.
● Established MSCI as a trusted resource by providing expert research, data and insights to policymakers regarding market practices.
|Embrace technology and innovation to drive operational improvements|
● Assessed technology stack across both Compliance and Internal Audit to improve scale and speed of monitoring and testing activities.
● Benchmarked against market leading enabling technology tools, which include Power BI, artificial intelligence/machine learning, data analytics and robotic process automation.
● Evaluated program design, implementation and effectiveness against regulatory guidance and published areas of regulatory scrutiny and focus.
|Actively champion and promote a department and company commitment to a culture of DE&I that moves from awareness to action|
● Closely partnered with and advised Chief Diversity Officer on DE&I initiatives and disclosures, including pay equity, diversity reporting, goal setting, ERG programming and recruiting activities.
● Served as Executive Sponsor and vocal advocate for the Black Leadership Network, an MSCI ERG focused on enhancing the recruitment, development, retention and promotion of Black employees.
● Raised MSCI’s DE&I leadership profile by becoming a signatory to the General Counsel Pledge to support the American Bar Association’s Resolution 113, which aims to enhance diversity in the legal profession through law firm disclosure of diversity data.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||79|
Actual cash incentives paid in respect of 2021 were based on actual performance against the financial, KPI and DE&I targets under the AIP as set forth in the table below. Given our strong financial performance, coupled with target payouts on the KPI goals, our NEOs received cash incentives for 2021 that were approximately equal to their target values.
|2021 Target||2021 Financial Payout
(70% Weighting at Target)
|2021 KPI Payout (20%
Weighting at Target)
|2021 DE&I Goals
|2021 Total Actual|
|Henry A. Fernandez||1,400,000||1,354,092||138.2%||308,008||110.0%||154,000||110.0%||1,816,100||129.7%|
|Andrew C. Wiechmann||600,000||580,325||138.2%||126,005||105.0%||60,000||100.0%||766,330||127.7%|
|C. D. Baer Pettit(1)||1,238,139||1,197,539||138.2%||272,393||110.0%||123,814||100.0%||1,593,746||128.7%|
|Scott A. Crum||700,000||677,046||138.2%||154,004||110.0%||77,000||110.0%||908,050||129.7%|
|Robert J. Gutowski||650,000||628,686||138.2%||136,504||105.0%||71,500||110.0%||836,690||128.7%|
|(1)||The actual cash incentive bonus amount paid to Mr. Pettit was converted from British pounds sterling to U.S. dollars using the fiscal year average of daily spot rates of £1 to $1.37571.|
Long-Term Equity Incentive Compensation Program
The Compensation Committee believes that MSCI’s executive compensation program should reinforce a pay-for-performance culture that aligns the interests of our senior executives with those of our shareholders by incorporating the achievement of multi-year performance metrics into variable compensation awards (in addition to the annual financial metrics applicable to cash incentive awards under the AIP).
While equity-based awards are typically granted on an annual basis under our LTIP program, we also periodically grant off-cycle LTIP awards (e.g., for new hire grants, replacement grants, retention grants, etc.). The grant date for such awards is determined on an individual basis, typically based on the applicable start date or the date of the event that triggered the award.
In 2021, the Company’s long-term equity incentive compensation program largely stayed the same compared to 2020, and we followed our typical practice for granting annual LTIP awards in early February 2021 following the regularly scheduled annual meeting of the Compensation Committee in late January 2021.
In 2021, the Compensation Committee continued to place a strong emphasis on pay for performance by granting a significant portion of equity incentive awards in the form of PSUs that are subject to multi-year TSR-based performance metrics, which the Compensation Committee believes more closely align the Executive Committee’s goals with those of the Company’s shareholders and complement the annual financial metrics applicable to cash incentive awards under the AIP.
The Compensation Committee approved the grant of two types of 2021 PSU awards to the members of the Company’s Executive Committee, including the NEOs: 3-Year PSUs and 5-Year PSUs. Given the generally positive feedback on the rigor of the TSR CAGR goals we received in the past from our shareholders, the Compensation Committee carried forward the absolute TSR CAGR performance metric for the 2021 PSUs. As detailed below, the Compensation Committee also granted RSUs to all NEOs other than Messrs. Fernandez and Pettit.
Additionally, to further promote our “owner-operator” mindset, the Compensation Committee added a one-year post-vest mandatory holding period to our annual 2021 3-Year PSUs that were granted to our NEOs, where such shares, or rights with respect to such shares, may not be transferred until the expiration of such holding period.
The Compensation Committee believes that the grant of 2021 PSUs to the Executive Committee members provides greater incentives for the execution of the Company’s strategic plan and the creation of additional value-enhancing corporate development initiatives.
|80||MSCI | COMPENSATION MATTERS|
2021 Equity Mix
The table below sets forth the allocation of 2021 RSUs, 3-Year PSUs and 5-Year PSUs granted to the NEOs. As reflected in the table below, in 2021, Mr. Fernandez and Mr. Pettit received 100% of their equity incentive compensation in the form of PSUs. For 2021, the Compensation Committee increased the proportion of Mr. Pettit’s 5-Year PSUs to 60% of his overall equity compensation in 2021 (with the remaining 40% granted in the form of 3-Year PSUs). We believe this change further aligns the interests of Mr. Pettit with those of our shareholders and reinforce our “owner-operator” philosophy and the execution of our strategic plan.
|Vehicle||CEO||President & COO||Other NEOs|
RSUs are inherently aligned with the interest of our shareholders because they are linked to share price appreciation. They also increase the retentive value of our overall compensation program. RSUs granted in 2021 vest in equal annual installments on each of the first, second and third anniversaries of the grant date, subject generally to continued employment with the Company. While these RSU awards do not have explicit performance-vesting conditions, the ultimate value that will be delivered to our NEOs from these awards depends on our future stock price performance.
The 3-Year PSUs and 5-Year PSUs granted in 2021 will cliff-vest on February 2, 2024 and February 2, 2026, respectively, subject generally to the executive’s continued employment with the Company and the Company’s level of achievement of the applicable absolute TSR CAGR performance metric measured over a three-year performance period and five-year performance period, respectively.
In determining the target value of and appropriate mix for the 2021 PSUs, the Compensation Committee took into consideration the executive’s performance and potential future contributions, the executive’s overall career experience, peer group analyses, and the risk profile of the compensation program for the executive.
The table below sets forth the target value for each NEO’s equity awards for 2021. Under SEC disclosure rules, we are required to disclose the accounting value for the RSUs and PSUs granted to the NEOs in 2021 in the “Summary Compensation Table”. As such, the target values reflected in the table below may differ from the amounts set forth in the Summary Compensation Table for such awards for 2021.
|Henry A. Fernandez||—||3,000,000||4,500,000|
|Andrew C. Wiechmann||270,000||315,000||315,000|
|C. D. Baer Pettit||—||1,600,000||2,400,000|
|Scott A. Crum(1)||360,000||420,000||420,000|
|Robert J. Gutowski||270,000||315,000||315,000|
|(1)||The table above does not reflect one-time retention RSUs granted to Mr. Crum in early 2021 with a grant date value of $275,000, in recognition of his leadership and dedication supporting our employees and clients during the COVID-19 pandemic.|
The 3-Year PSUs and 5-Year PSUs reflect the ability to receive between 0% and 300% and 0% and 200%, respectively, of the target number of shares based on achievement of the TSR CAGR performance metric over the applicable performance period.
The table below sets forth the TSR CAGR performance percentage for the 3-Year PSUs. There will be interpolation (rounded to two decimal places) to derive a TSR CAGR performance percentage that is not expressly set forth in the table below, and any resulting fractional shares will be rounded down to the nearest whole share.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||81|
3-Year PSU TSR CAGR Performance Percentage
|TSR CAGR (%)||Performance Percentage (%)|
|≥ 30.0 (maximum)||300|
|< 8.0||No Vesting|
The table below sets forth the TSR CAGR performance percentage for the 5-Year PSUs. There will be interpolation (rounded to two decimal places) to derive a TSR CAGR performance percentage that is not expressly set forth in the table below, and any resulting fractional shares will be rounded down to the nearest whole share.
5-Year PSU TSR CAGR Performance Percentage
|TSR CAGR (%)||Performance Percentage (%)|
|≥ 20.0 (maximum)||200|
The Compensation Committee established the above TSR performance goal percentages applicable to the 3-Year PSUs and the 5-Year PSUs after considering historical 3- and 5-year TSR performance of S&P 500 companies and MSCI’s business projections. The Compensation Committee believes that the applicable threshold, target and maximum goals established for both PSU vehicles in 2021 represent rigorous hurdles that would ultimately deliver significant shareholder value creation if achieved, as evidenced by the fact that achievement of the TSR performance goals at the threshold performance levels applicable to the 2021 3-Year PSUs and 5-Year PSUs would translate to substantial growth in our shareholders’ investments over such performance period, as reflected in the chart below.
|82||MSCI | COMPENSATION MATTERS|
2019 PSU AWARD PAYOUTS
The three-year performance period applicable to the PSUs granted to each of Messrs. Fernandez, Wiechmann, Pettit, Crum and Gutowski on February 6, 2019 concluded on February 5, 2022 and resulted in the following level of achievement:
|Performance Period: 2019-2022|
|Performance Metric||Target||Achievement||% Payout|
|TSR CAGR||10.00%||≥ 30.00%||300%|
Following the performance adjustment, Mr. Fernandez received 80,187 PSUs, Mr. Wiechmann received 3,021 PSUs, Mr. Pettit received 37,008 PSUs, Mr. Crum received 10,854 PSUs and Mr. Gutowski received 3,021 PSUs, which such PSUs vested and converted to shares on February 7, 2022.
2022 Long-Term Equity Incentive Compensation Program
In order to continue to promote the alignment of executive compensation and long-term shareholder value creation, the Compensation Committee adopted enhancements to the Company’s long-term equity incentive compensation program for 2022, while continuing to place a strong emphasis on maintaining and enhancing our “owner-operator” culture by granting a significant portion of equity incentive awards in the form of performance-based awards, specifically PSUs and PSOs.
Additional information on our 2022 LTIP is provided in the section titled “Key 2022 Compensation Decisions” on page 61 of this Proxy Statement.
2022 Equity Mix
The table below sets forth the target value for each NEO’s 2022 annual equity awards:
|Henry A. Fernandez||—||5,000,000||5,000,000|
|Andrew C. Wiechmann||390,000||455,000||455,000|
|C.D. Baer Pettit||—||2,750,000||2,750,000|
|Scott A. Crum||495,000||577,500||577,500|
|Robert J. Gutowski||360,000||420,000||420,000|
The Company provides health, welfare and other benefits to remain competitive in hiring and retaining its employees. Our NEOs are eligible to participate in these benefit plans on the same terms and conditions as all other employees. We do not provide any special or enhanced benefits to our NEOs.
In the United States and the United Kingdom, the Company has established defined contribution plans for all eligible employees. Contributions by the Company to these defined contribution plans for our NEOs for the applicable period are disclosed in the “All Other Compensation” column in the Summary Compensation Table below.
All of the NEOs are employed on an “at-will” basis, and the Company does not have any individual employment agreements with the NEOs providing for a fixed duration of employment. As a result, the Company has the flexibility to alter or revise its compensation programs as circumstances dictate.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||83|
Under Mr. Wiechmann’s offer letter with the Company and Mr. Pettit’s employment letter with a subsidiary of the Company, in the event of an involuntary termination of employment without cause, each of Messrs. Wiechmann and Pettit is eligible to receive, subject to his compliance with certain conditions, (i) a lump sum cash payment equal to the sum of his then-current annual base salary plus target annual bonus opportunity and (ii) a prorated cash bonus under the AIP for the year of termination based on actual performance through the date of termination (as of December 31, 2021, assuming 100% achievement of the annual bonus opportunity, such amounts would have equaled $1,700,000 for Mr. Wiechmann and $3,336,097 for Mr. Pettit; the amount for Mr. Pettit is shown as being paid in British pounds sterling and converted to U.S. dollars using the fiscal year average of daily spot rates of £1 to $1.37571 for fiscal 2021).
In addition, we maintain a Change in Control Severance Plan for the benefit of eligible senior executives of the Company (including the NEOs) that provides for severance benefits on a “double-trigger” basis—i.e., in the event of a qualifying termination of the executive’s employment by the Company without “cause” or by the participant for “good reason” in connection with a change in control.
Additional information on post-termination and change in control benefits for our NEOs, assuming a qualifying event occurred as of December 31, 2021, is provided in the section titled “Potential Payments upon Termination or Change in Control,” on page 91 of this Proxy Statement.
No Excessive Perquisites
Based on the Company’s philosophy that its executive compensation program should be straightforward and directly linked to performance, the compensation program for the NEOs does not include any excessive perquisites, excise tax gross-ups or supplemental executive retirement benefits.
The Compensation Committee believes that significant stock ownership at the senior-most levels of MSCI’s leadership (e.g., the Executive Committee), which includes our executive officers, aligns management’s interests with those of our shareholders and encourages an “owner-operator” mindset. As part of the Compensation Committee’s ongoing assessment of the Company’s compensation policies and practices to ensure furtherance of the goals identified above and for alignment with best practices, effective January 1, 2019, the Compensation Committee adopted the rigorous stock ownership guidelines detailed below. On January 25, 2022, the Compensation Committee further amended the stock ownership guidelines to adopt more rigorous requirements that reflect among the highest multiples of base salary in our peer group, as detailed below. As of the date of this Proxy Statement, all Executive Committee members, including our NEOs, are in compliance with both the pre-2022 Stock Ownership Guidelines and the current Stock Ownership Guidelines. Our CEO significantly exceeds his applicable stock ownership guidelines (see page 100 of this Proxy Statement for additional details).
Guidelines (Effective 2022)
|Chief Executive Officer||12x base salary||6x base salary|
|President & Chief Operating Officer||12x base salary||4x base salary|
|Other Management Committee Members, including other NEOs||8x base salary||3x base salary|
|Executive Committee||4x base salary||3x base salary|
All Executive Committee members are required to meet the applicable ownership guidelines under the current Stock Ownership Guidelines within five years following the date of such executive’s appointment to the Executive Committee (or, if later, five years from January 1, 2019). For the purpose of determining whether each individual is in compliance with these stock ownership guidelines and requirements, the following are counted towards satisfaction of the minimum ownership requirements:
|(1)||shares beneficially owned individually, directly or indirectly;|
|(2)||shares beneficially owned jointly with, or separately by, immediate family members residing in the same household, either directly or indirectly; and|
|(3)||“Net Shares” underlying unvested RSUs, unvested PSUs (solely to the extent of any award minimum—i.e., any unvested PSUs that are subject to achievement of outstanding performance goals are not counted), “in-the money” vested stock options and any other vested or unvested equity awards (as determined in the Compensation Committee’s discretion).|
|84||MSCI | COMPENSATION MATTERS|
“Net Shares” means the number of shares that would remain if the shares underlying the equity awards are sold or withheld by the Company to (i) pay the exercise price of a stock option, (ii) satisfy any tax withholding obligations (assuming a tax rate of 50%) or (iii) satisfy any other applicable transaction costs.
Until the expected ownership levels are achieved, each Executive Committee member is required to retain 50% of the Net Shares resulting from the vesting, settlement or exercise, as applicable of all stock options, RSUs, PSUs or other equity awards granted to such executive.
The Compensation Committee determined that increasing the share ownership multiples for the President and Chief Operating Officer and other senior leaders, including our NEOs, better reflected alignment with the broader responsibilities of those roles.
In addition to the minimum ownership requirements, in 2022, the Compensation Committee approved revisions to the share retention requirements of the stock ownership guidelines to provide that until an executive ceases to serve on the Company’s Executive Committee, such executive will be required to retain a number of shares equivalent to, in the aggregate, 25% of the “Net Shares” resulting from the vesting, settlement or exercise, as applicable, of all equity incentive awards granted to such executive after January 1, 2022 (or, if later, the date such executive becomes a member of the Executive Committee). The Compensation Committee determined that the addition of this 25% “Net Shares” holding requirement would further enhance our goal of ensuring an “owner-operator” mindset among senior leaders. This approach will ensure that a portion of the Net Shares received from every award will be retained while an individual serves on the Executive Committee.
In 2019, the Board expanded the Company’s Clawback Policy beyond financial results or operating metrics that were achieved as a result of willful misconduct or intentional or fraudulent conduct. Under the revised Clawback Policy, the Board, acting upon the recommendation of the Compensation Committee, may to the extent permitted by applicable law, recoup any incentive compensation (cash and equity) received by members of the Executive Committee and the Company’s Principal Accounting Officer, in the event of a restatement of financial or other performance-based measures (regardless of whether detrimental conduct has occurred) or in the event that detrimental conduct results in an increased level of performance goal achievement or otherwise causes material financial and/or reputational harm to the Company, as described below.
In the case of a restatement of financial or other performance-based measures, the Board may recover up to the amount by which the incentive compensation received exceeds the amount that would have been received if the error had not been made within the two years preceding the date on which the Board determines that the financial or other measure contains a material error.
In the case of detrimental conduct that, in the sole discretion of the Board, has resulted in a level of achievement of a performance-based measure or caused material financial or reputational harm to the Company, the Board may recover incentive compensation received by the person during the two-year period immediately preceding the date on which such person engaged in such detrimental conduct (or the date on which the Compensation Committee discovers that such person engaged in detrimental conduct). Detrimental conduct consists of:
|●||willful misconduct or breach of a fiduciary duty with respect to the Company or any of its subsidiaries;|
|●||conviction of, or having entered a plea bargain or settlement admitting guilt for, any crime of moral turpitude or felony under any applicable law with respect to the Company or any of its subsidiaries;|
|●||commission of an act of fraud, embezzlement or misappropriation, with respect to the Company or any of its subsidiaries;|
|●||failure to take action with respect to any acts or conduct described above when taken by another person that such person has actual knowledge of or directing any other person to take any of the actions described above; and|
|●||breach of any restrictive covenant to which such person is subject contained in any applicable agreement or arrangement with the Company or any of its subsidiaries.|
The expanded Clawback Policy applies to all incentive compensation (cash and equity) granted on or after February 7, 2019. Incentive compensation granted prior to that date remains subject to our prior Clawback Policy.
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||85|
We prohibit all directors and employees, including all NEOs, from hedging or pledging the Company’s common stock or engaging in short sales, purchases or sales of options, puts or calls, as well as derivatives such as swaps, forwards or futures and trading on a short-term basis in the Company’s common stock.
The Compensation Committee takes into consideration the tax implications of our executive compensation program, including with respect to the tax deductibility of compensation paid under Section 162(m) of the IRC.
In the exercise of its business judgment, and in accordance with its compensation philosophy, the Compensation Committee continues to have flexibility to award compensation that is not tax deductible if it determines that such award is in our shareholders’ best interests and is necessary to comply with contractual commitments, or to maintain flexibility needed to attract talent, promote retention or recognize and reward desired performance.
The Compensation Committee believes that the design, implementation and governance of our executive compensation program are consistent with high standards of risk management. Our executive compensation program reflects an appropriate mix of compensation elements, balancing current and long-term performance objectives, cash and equity compensation, and risks and rewards.
|●||The compensation framework used for making compensation decisions is multi-faceted as it incorporates multiple metrics over varying time periods and is subject to the application of informed judgment by the Compensation Committee.|
|●||To further ensure that the interests of our NEOs are aligned with those of our shareholders, a significant portion of executive officer long-term incentive compensation is awarded as equity subject to vesting requirements. Awards typically vest over a multi-year period, and in the case of performance-based awards, vest based on achievement of applicable performance goals at the end of a relevant performance period.|
|●||Executive Committee members are required to meet the applicable stock ownership guidelines described under “Stock Ownership Guidelines” on page 83 of this Proxy Statement.|
|●||Incentive compensation is subject to the Clawback Policy described under “Clawback Policy” on page 84 of this Proxy Statement.|
Based on these features, we believe our executive compensation program effectively (i) ensures that our compensation opportunities do not encourage excessive risk taking, (ii) keeps our NEOs focused on the creation of long-term, sustainable value for our shareholders and (iii) provides competitive and appropriate levels of compensation over time.
In 2021, the Compensation Committee reviewed our compensation policies as generally applicable to all of our employees and believes that our policies do not encourage excessive or unnecessary risk-taking and that any level of risk they do encourage is not reasonably likely to have a material adverse effect on the Company. Semler Brossy assisted the Compensation Committee with its review of our compensation program by reviewing materials provided by management related to our compensation program, including the Company’s LTIP. The Compensation Committee also reviewed materials previously prepared by a third-party consultant related to certain of the Company’s variable incentive plans, including the AIP, from a risk and governance perspective.
|86||MSCI | COMPENSATION MATTERS|
We, the Compensation, Talent and Culture Committee of the Board of Directors of MSCI Inc., have reviewed and discussed with management the Compensation Discussion and Analysis above. Based on this review and these discussions, the Compensation, Talent and Culture Committee recommended to the Board that the Compensation Discussion and Analysis be included in this Proxy Statement and incorporated by reference into the Company’s 2021 Annual Report on Form 10-K filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission.
Linda H. Riefler (Chair)
Marcus L. Smith
|2022 PROXY STATEMENT||87|
The following table sets forth information regarding compensation paid or awarded by MSCI to the Company’s NEOs during fiscal years 2021, 2020 and 2019.
|Name and Principal Position||Fiscal
|Henry A. Fernandez||2021||1,000,000||—||7,499,592||1,816,100||22,620||10,338,312|
|Chief Executive Officer||2019||1,000,000||—||6,499,950||1,734,320||21,690||9,255,960|
|Andrew C. Wiechmann||2021||500,000||—||899,268||766,330||68,780||2,234,378|
|Chief Financial Officer||2020||500,000||—||499,836||525,970||72,364||1,598,170|
|C.D. Baer Pettit||2021||859,819||—||3,999,665||1,593,746||90,215||6,543,445|
|Chief Operating Officer||2019||798,256||—||2,999,797||1,406,743||165,788||5,370,583|
|Chief Human Resources Officer||2020||550,000||—||1,199,683||701,110||33,342||2,484,135|
|Robert J. Gutowski||2021||450,000||—||899,268||836,268||55,823||2,241,781|
|(1)||Base salary for Mr. Pettit was paid in British pounds sterling and converted to U.S. dollars using the fiscal year average of daily spot rates of £1 to $1.375710, $1.283605 and $1.277209 for fiscal 2021, 2020 and 2019, respectively. Mr. Pettit’s 2021 base salary rate was £625,000.|
|(2)||Represents the grant date fair value of awards granted during each fiscal year, as computed in accordance with FASB ASC Topic 718, excluding the effect of estimated forfeitures, and does not reflect whether the NEO will actually receive a financial benefit from the award. The awards reported in this column were granted in February 2019, February 2020 and February 2021 as part of the annual compensation process. The following table represents the grant date fair value of awards granted during February 2021:|
|GRANT DATE FAIR VALUE OF STOCK UNITS GRANTED DURING 2021 ($)|
|Henry A. Fernandez||—||7,499,592||7,499,592|
|Andrew C. Wiechmann||269,715||629,553||899,268|
|C.D. Baer Pettit||—||3,999,665||3,999,665|
|Scott A. Crum||634,476||839,456||1,473,932|
|Robert J. Gutowski||269,715||629,553||899,268|